search

s60sc / ESP32-CAM_MJPEG2SD

ESP32 Camera motion capture application to record JPEGs to SD card as AVI files and stream to browser as MJPEG. If a microphone is installed then a WAV file is also created. Files can be uploaded via FTP or downloaded to browser.
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
931 stars 214 forks source link

Able to display video after replacing v8.8 with v9.3 but error in motion detection #326

Closed YapCK45 closed 10 months ago

YapCK45 commented 11 months ago

Downloaded v9.3 and replaced the ESPCam with v8.8 and surprisingly, it is able to display the video. Error message when motion detect is enabled:'

[03:34:46.313 updateAppStatus] Enabling motion detection E (570579) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [03:34:46.454 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed

No problem with manual recording: [03:44:59.253 processFrame] Capture started by Button ............................ [03:45:07.256 closeAvi] **** AVI recording stats **** [03:45:07.256 closeAvi] Recorded /20231220/20231220_034459_UXGA_4_8_28.avi

s60sc commented 11 months ago

bad frame from cam - it happens, only an issue if it happens a lot

YapCK45 commented 11 months ago

It happens a lot and stopped only when I disable motion detect. See log below: [12:27:23.165 updateAppStatus] Enabling motion detection E (77239) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:23.289 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (77439) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:23.489 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (77639) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:23.689 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (77839) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:23.889 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (78039) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:24.089 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (78239) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:24.289 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (78439) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:24.489 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (78639) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:24.689 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (78840) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:24.889 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (79039) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:25.089 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (79239) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:25.289 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (79439) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:25.489 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (79639) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:25.689 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (79839) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:25.889 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (80039) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:26.089 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (80239) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:26.289 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (80439) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:26.489 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (80639) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:26.689 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (80839) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:26.889 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (81039) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:27.089 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (81239) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:27.289 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (81439) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:27.489 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (81639) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:27.689 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (81839) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:27.889 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (82039) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:28.089 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (82239) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:28.289 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (82439) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:28.489 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (82639) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:28.689 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (82839) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:28.889 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed E (83039) esp_jpg_decode: JPG Decompression Failed! Parameter error [12:27:29.089 ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187] motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed [12:27:29.210 updateAppStatus] Disabling motion detection

YapCK45 commented 11 months ago

Also has the same problem of no display which I mentioned in issue #320. The same hardware was running v8.8 without any problem. So cannot be hardware.

s60sc commented 11 months ago

jpeg decoding only occurs during motion detection, and the errors are bad frames from a faulty cam

philippedc commented 11 months ago

Hi, many thanks for sharing this so great project. Now I have some issues: 1- I first installed the last version - v9.3 - and I cannot get any picture on the browser. Motion is working, recording is working, (I do not use telegram). Note that filenames on SDCard are very strange sdcard-9 3

2- I then installed the past version - v8.8 - and I still cannot get any picture on the browser. This time with an error message on the browser v8 8

192.168.1.14 is the ESP32-CAM IP address

YapCK45 commented 11 months ago

@s60sc : I compared the relevant section for motionDetect.cpp for v9.3 can v8.8 and they looked the same:

if (!jpg2rgb((uint8_t*)fb->buf, fb->len, &rgb_buf, (jpg_scale_t)scaling)) { LOG_ERR("motionDetect: jpg2rgb() failed"); free(rgb_buf); rgb_buf = NULL; return motionStatus; }

This issue does not affect v8.8. So I don't think it is due to faulty cam.

Can I suggest ignoring the error if there are just some frames. It is not realistic to expect a perfect sensor from a low cost chip such as the ESPCam. I reckoned a few missed frames should not affect the motion detection much. Perhaps it may be less sensitive but it will certainly make the system more robust.

YapCK45 commented 11 months ago

@philippedc I encountered this problem before. I think your SD card was corrupted. @s60sc : Your comment please.

s60sc commented 11 months ago

When installing a different version make sure it is a full clean install including data files

philippedc commented 11 months ago

@YapCK45 it is very strange. I've tried with 2 SDCard of 8Go each. Before insert them to the ESP-CAM I formatted them and test a file copy. With v9.3 The first 8Go does not generate error message, therefor it became a raw device so I cannot control its content with Windows file explorer. The second 8Go is not recognized by the camera, even if all work controls are well performed with Windows 10 I do not understand.... Nevertheless whatever the SDCard inserted, with no SDCard error message, I cannot get any picture from the web browser. Console messages says that recording and motion works fine.

philippedc commented 11 months ago

Here is the console message at starting withe the "raw device SDCard" console

s60sc commented 11 months ago

As per release notes, if using an earlier release you can't use downloaded files which cause 404, you must copy them manually from earlier release zip

philippedc commented 11 months ago

When installing a different version make sure it is a full clean install including data files

yes that what I've done. When there is not console error message whatever the sdcard used, is there a relationship between sdcard and the fact the camera is not remotely viewable ?

philippedc commented 11 months ago

Just to clarify I've tried several examples from https://github.com/eloquentarduino/EloquentSurveillance (with the good 8Go SDCard that is not recognized by ESP32-CAM_MJPEG2SD) and streaming and motion capture work fine.

TotallyNotChloe commented 11 months ago

About the motion detection error, its also happening to me, same message and everything. Seems to be a error related to bigger resolutions, i lowered it and it seems to have stopped.

Weird thing is that it didn't happened on older versions. just on this new one.

also had a lot of boot loops, had to reinstall multiple times until it stopped.

s60sc commented 11 months ago

camera can output bad frames which prevents the frame being decoded for motion detection. camera modules have varying build quality.

YapCK45 commented 11 months ago

I could replicate @TotallyNotChloe's comment that lowering the resolution seems to solve the motion detect issue. I could get up to sxga(1280X1024). Moving to HD would trigger the ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187.

Perhaps it could be due to a imperfect sensor, but then it works on v8.8. Not sure how esp_jpg_decode works. Suggest to trigger ERROR @ motionDetect.cpp:187 only if they occur on multiple times in succesion. This will make it more robust.

In summary, using the same hardware. The corresponding data folders are used and updated manually.

version motionDetect streamVideo for display
v8.8 OK OK
v9.3 NOK NOK