search

sa-tre / satre-specification

Standard Architecture for Trusted Research Environments specification
https://satre-specification.readthedocs.io
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
18 stars 8 forks source link

[Discussion]: Mismatch between Archimate and SATRE #312

Open manics opened 2 months ago

manics commented 2 months ago

Summary

There are discrepancies between the Archimate files and SATRE

Source

No response

Detail

There are some mismatches between what's described in the Archimate files published in https://zenodo.org/records/10053383, and what we have in SATRE v1. This includes:

Intended Output

We should make a list of all discrepancies, and resolve them for the next version of SATRE

Who can help

No response

heikkil commented 2 months ago

The attached Archi view shows the roles in the specification at the top with my notes and, for comparison, the roles in the distributed archimate file. image

heikkil commented 2 months ago

From my perspective, the main challence in the presentation of SATRE specification is that requirements are only in the online specification. They are the core of the specification and need to see them as part of the architecture.

I am attaching my current Archi file that contains all relevant texts from the specification. Also, I've added links between views that make it easier to navigate between them. I hope this helps others to understand the SATRE and take it forward.

To open it in Archi, rename 'satre-20240422.txt' to 'satre-20240422.architecture'. satre-20240422.txt