search

sadellie / unitto

😎 Superior Calculator and Converter for Android
https://sadellie.github.io/unitto
GNU General Public License v3.0
397 stars 35 forks source link

Button Animation not working properly #162

Closed heschy2 closed 8 months ago

heschy2 commented 9 months ago

In Google Calculator you can tap on a button and it temporarily transforms into a squircle (or whatever that is).

In unitto, the animation is not properly implemented: The button has to be hold in order for the animation to work. The tranformation is imideatly interrupted when the finger leaves the display. This behaiviour should only occur when the Transformation is complete:

Current: Tap -> Not enough time to trnasform Hold -> Transforms and detransforms when finger is lifted

Expected: Tap -> Complete transformation with imidieate detransformation AFTER the animation completed Hold -> current

heschy2 commented 8 months ago

Hi, as far as I understood, the Issue was resolved and is fixed in the newest Version, however I just recieved the F-Droid Update to the Version "Quick Silver", and the Issue is still persistent.

sadellie commented 8 months ago

Everything works as expected. I am not developing a Google Calculator clone.

heschy2 commented 8 months ago

Of course not, Unitto is way better than GCalc. But this animation looks weird, and design is one of the only things where cloning Google is good. The design of Unitto is already pretty "inspired" by GCalc, so the Animation does not make a real difference in that regard.

As a developer I absolutely agree that of course you can decide what Unitto should look and behave like.

But as a User, I have to tell you that this animation is weird, and doing it how google does it would improve the experience and Users would apreciate it.

But as I said, of course I respect if you decide not to do that, thats perfectly okay.