[Fileverse Safe App] Relaying doesn't work with W3A

kirkkonen commented 7 months ago

Bug description

When relaying a Safe App transaction with a social wallet, nothing happens.

Environment

Browser: Chrome
Wallet: W3A
Chain: Gnosis Chain

Steps to reproduce

Login with W3A/Google
Go to a Safe App (e.g. Fileverse)
Create a transaction
Try executing the tx via the Relayer

Expected result

Tx should be executed or at least some meaningful error shown

Obtained result

Absolutely nothing happens

Screenshots

https://www.loom.com/share/15d82c90928541d98acdd7316d07ca95?sid=7cf6666d-bd97-4f45-82ce-1e6d0a1593da

Original report from Fileverse

Context can be found here: https://5afe.slack.com/archives/C03DAGWJCR5/p1700575086865789

Relayer Provider cancelling txns. -> Loom: https://www.loom.com/share/15d82c90928541d98acdd7316d07ca95?sid=7cf6666d-bd97-4f45-82ce-1e6d0a1593da -> Logjam with proper console logs & api calls: https://jam.dev/c/b2c2134f-3c8e-4a44-bdb2-94032accb649
UI becoming unusable by not allowing users to click. Log jam to help you investigate: https://jam.dev/c/e3f93c77-4abb-4e17-b81c-2e54274a7839 Safe tx hash (failed): 0x71b7628233bdbc1163ce5eda9a0c83dfab62773c5b906edb20e995bd8c9f4d74 All the API calls are also recorded in the logjam link for you to debug if issue is on the API Level. For eg, go the request you want to check in bottom right on this link: https://jam.dev/c/b2c2134f-3c8e-4a44-bdb2-94032accb649

And a successful one (if the relayer is not used): https://gnosisscan.io/tx/0xb2f23c467a42bc397ea20b40b57a509937b3a0729623944b95c7897595a0b962/

katspaugh commented 7 months ago

@kirkkonen from reading this issue it’s not really clear what needs to be done.

Please write a more succinct problem description and paste all the necessary info in the issue so that we don’t have to dig on slack.

Tip: if you start creating an issue from GitHub directly instead of the project board, there’s a helpful bug report template.

kirkkonen commented 6 months ago

Just found this comment. Kinda weird to put it on ice because you have to make 1 click to get into the Slack thread but I'll copy the original message for you here. I don't have any other context. Added you to the Telegram chat either. @katspaugh

Last week I got some more context on the bug reported by the Fileverse team. Quick facts: They face relayer error on deploying a Collaboration smart contract (portal) That's happening on Gnosis chain, not Goerli It is definitely unrelated to Seedless as it happened and was reported way before the release Some more details shared by Constantin from Fileverse: (1) This is the Fileverse App on Safe: https://app.safe.global/share/safe-app?appUrl=https%3A%2F%2Fportal.fileverse.io&chain=gno

Fileverse = collaboration smart contract deployed on Gnosis
On the Safe App, it's also only available for Safe on Gnosis

(2) In both the above error messages / relayer transaction issues, the users clicked on the Fileverse App and when deploying it they faced this relayer specific issue

To help, we tried to replicate from our side and we got the same issue for this flow: "google login". Here's a jam screenrecoding that I just did with my gmail and it shows you the screen + console errors directly: https://jam.dev/c/f628336d-5514-4f10-8d9d-6dd7cf185b79
Check 0:51

katspaugh commented 6 months ago

It looks like an issue with the combination of relaying and W3A.

@liliya-soroka @francovenica it's not a known bug, is it? Can you reproduce any problems when relaying with the social login?

liliya-soroka commented 6 months ago

I can not reproduce the issue . The portal was deployed successfully for my gnosis chain safe using Social Login + Relay / MM +Relay

usame-algan commented 1 month ago

Can this issue be closed since social wallet was sunset?

safe-global / safe-wallet-web