saft-project / saft

The SAFT forms
http://saftproject.com
138 stars 30 forks source link

How to determine readiness for Stage 4 deployment? #10

Open Sjors opened 6 years ago

Sjors commented 6 years ago

I'm replacing "step" with "stage" because I like the missile analogy :-)

schermafbeelding 2017-10-19 om 14 33 12

How does Developers Inc know that their token is ready for Stage 4? Premature deployment of that stage could lead to an explosion mid air, if the SEC still thinks the tokens are securities. Actual usage before Stage 4 might be a good indication of actual (rather than theoretical) utility, but that would require launching the network earlier.

Perhaps an additional stage can be added where only investors can use the token, but this raises at least two concerns: 1 - the investors are not necessarily the target audience, and in fact, they explicitly agree not to be the target audience in 6C of the form:

schermafbeelding 2017-10-19 om 14 41 04

2 - once investors have the tokens, it's hard to stop them from selling these tokens, which could lead to other problems 3 - investors on a vesting schedule, who have a longer time horizon, would not be able to test (as much)