sagiadinos / garlic-player

Digital Signage Player based on SMIL
https://garlic-player.com
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
88 stars 17 forks source link

Raspberry Pi version planned ? #17

Closed adalidortiz closed 4 years ago

adalidortiz commented 4 years ago

I´am very happy with garlic-player. Are you planned a Raspberry Pi version?

Many libraries here in Mexico have no money to buy a digital signage solution and expensive equipment to implement this kind of technology.

Gracias !!

sagiadinos commented 4 years ago

Last summer I test RPI4, but it was not stable enough (overheating) at that time. I also got some tests with RPI 3 and the Zero but it was not satisfying with the video libs I use.

In my opinion there is another caveat! So I recommend not to use a Raspberry Pi for Digital Signage at this moment. Especially not with apps like garlic-player which writes permanently and intensive log files for reporting and statistics. Sooner or later this will destroy standard microSD-Cards which are optimized only for reading. Some years ago I got some negative experiences with another player and consumer USB-Sticks. That is beside of the video issues with rpi3 one of the reasons why I did not look after a Raspberry version.

Look here if you need more detailed information on this topic. https://smil-control.com/digital-signage-and-raspberry-pi/

My current suggestion is to use a cheap multimedia player based on Android with eMMC-Flash. Search for at least Android 7.1.1, 2GB RAM and 8GB Flash (16GB and more if you need to play 4K Videos). The prizes should start with about 50 US$. But keep in mind that is cheap hardware without real support and updates.

Do not misunderstand me: The Raspberry Pi 4 in my opinion is a gorgeous machine and I normally prefer Linux over Android. If a future RPI include or supports eMMC-Flash, it would be a perfect match for Digital Signage.

adalidortiz commented 4 years ago

Thanks for the explanation. Actually I'm tested garlic-player on an Android TV box and work very well.

Many thanks !!!