Diff Swedish bath waters between API badplatsen.havochvatten.se/badplatsen/api 2686 and uploaded bath waters 438

[salgo60]

We find 439 Swedish bathing waters in https://discomap.eea.europa.eu/Bathingwater/

In API badplatsen/api/feature we have 2686 and in Wikidata we have additional some in this projects > 2700

• see also notebook - Sweden is SE

[soleildeminuit]

The badplatsen/api/feature API has an attribute euType (a boolean flag) that, according to the docs, indicates whether the site is to reported to EU or not (in Swedish "Flagga som anger om badet är ett EU bad eller ej")

table(testLocations$euType)

FALSE TRUE 2155 440

[salgo60]

Good catch then the question is

• do we have Nutskod for 2155
• do we have bathingWaterIdentifier for just 440 or 2155

I guess https://dd.eionet.europa.eu/dataelements/99263 states that "Must be a valid bathing water identifier in the "WFDProtectedArea" registry"

Next step: we need to speak with people administrating the Swedish database and understand if we need one or two identifiers in Wikidata for supporting EUbaths and Swedish bath waters with euType = False

• I guess if we start use the suggested bathingWaterIdentifier field for things not registered at the "WFDProtectedArea" registry" we are just creating a mess..a rose is a rose is a rose ;-)

[soleildeminuit]

I agree, best to stick to established nomenclature...We do have nutsCode for all of them, but the term bathingWaterIdentifier does not exist in the API. There are more test locations/sites then what I mentioned, the import fails for a couple of dozens, probably due to data quality issues.

[soleildeminuit]

Not all of the nutsCode has an associated test location profile, for example: https://badplatsen.havochvatten.se/badplatsen/api/testlocationprofile/SE0930861000004814

[salgo60]

Do we have a good specification of the NUTScode?

In Wikidata we call it Property:P605 and have a regexp [A-Z]{2}[A-Z0-9]{0,3}

and a formatter URL http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabularyconcept/common/nuts/$1 ==>

• Sweden -> list what we have in WD for Sweden
• bath water NUTScode -> dont follow this pattern and is not in the db e.g.
  • SE0241884000004954 http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabularyconcept/common/nuts/SE0241884000004954 same as WD Q106712205
  • SE0110136000002142 http://dd.eionet.europa.eu/vocabularyconcept/common/nuts/SE0110136000002142 same as WD Q49099077

[salgo60]

@anderselias SE0930861000004814 see https://github.com/salgo60/Svenskabadplatser/issues/33

• do you have a list of them I guess all of them are errors in Wikidata...

Update found those 3

• SE0930861000004814 --> https://github.com/salgo60/Svenskabadplatser/issues/33
• SE0110191000004834 --> https://github.com/salgo60/Svenskabadplatser/issues/34
• SE0241884000004954 --> https://github.com/salgo60/Svenskabadplatser/issues/32