search

sandeepmistry / node-sensortag

Node.js lib for the TI SensorTag
MIT License
218 stars 111 forks source link

Big difference in power consumption when using this lib with iMac versus rpi3 raspbian #92

Open danielbh opened 7 years ago

danielbh commented 7 years ago

Hello!

First I used this script: https://github.com/danielbh/sensortag-battery-test/blob/master/polling.js Then I followed this guide: http://mobilemodding.info/2015/06/ti-sensortag-2-power-consumption-analysys/

I tested this script on a iMac I bought this year and rpi3 from last year.

On the iMac when connecting and polling the sensors I'm getting: ~0.01 mA -0.20 mA and it looks like the iMac is actively optimizing the bluetooth connection to preserve the battery life of the sensor because the mA is rarely over 0.15.

However on the raspberry pi something quite different is occurring. I'm getting no less than 0.50 mA and it is staying consistently above that, even when the sensors are not being read.

Any idea what is going on or where I could begin investigating this problem? Thanks for any help you could offer.

danielbh commented 7 years ago

Update... when connecting to a sensor using bluetoothctl only I'm gettting 0.09 mA - 0.18 mA power consumption

steps to repeat...

  1. apt get install bluez bluez-utils
  2. type command bluetoothctl (to get to command line utility)
  3. turn on sensortag (with power consumption monitoring on... see this video )
  4. type scan on
  5. then connect <sensortag address xx:xx:xx:xx:xx:xx> (I think you have to make sure scan is off scan off)
  6. note power consumption.
danielbh commented 7 years ago

Made a quick and dirty test with noble directly. Just keep restarting script until you connect to the sensortag. The result was the same as the sensortag script above. ~0.5 mA.

https://github.com/danielbh/sensortag-battery-test/blob/master/noble-connection-tester.js

What are your thoughts on this? Thanks.

danielbh commented 7 years ago

Updating the firmware to 1.3 seems to make this issue worse. It runs then at ~0.6 mA!

sandeepmistry commented 7 years ago

@danielbh please provide an HCI dump capture: sudo hcidump -t -x.

How are you measuring the power consumption?