search

sanderland / katrain

Improve your Baduk skills by training with KataGo!
Other
1.62k stars 227 forks source link

Performance throughout the game overview/rating #388

Closed sektorate closed 3 years ago

sektorate commented 3 years ago

Hello, many thanks for this amazing trainer! Feature suggestion: I imagine each move being placed in categories (e.g. blunder, mistake, inaccuracy, okay, excellent, best move) based on the percentage change in winrate it effects. The percentage ranges for these categories could be user definable. An overall "accuracy" score out of 100 could then be generated for each player based on the percentage of their moves the engine rates as best. These ideas are inspired by the analysis features of chess.com, that give an overall insight into the players' performance in a game; this would supplement analysis of each individual move. Thanks again for your work, I'd love to hear your thoughts. Screenshot (2)

sanderland commented 3 years ago

image seems wrong value >100% I think this bug was fixed and you have an old commit

Eric-Wainwright commented 3 years ago

For statistics and the point losses, you could report both the percentage and absolute count where needed together, instead of having separate columns, or not reporting both values. I don't think the order matters. Also, there would then be no need to put "%" in the labels.

image

xiaoyifang commented 3 years ago

as already there are many suggestions now :-) . I recommend this image

in the upper area ,the better value have a significant background color (green etc). the lower part 's ,the player's bar can be aligned together.

the advantage of this is ,just one glimpse ,you know who does better.and which value is higher . without the need to read the number.

sanderland commented 3 years ago

Closing this as it's soon released, but feel free to continue discussion.