sanskrit-lexicon / MWS

Monier Monier-Williams, Sir; A Sanskrit-English dictionary. Oxford, 1899
Other
7 stars 5 forks source link

Error in latest digital editions (absent in older) #1

Closed gasyoun closed 9 years ago

gasyoun commented 10 years ago

Hope this case helps find similar issues as well. Based on https://groups.google.com/forum/#!searchin/nagari/sandic/nagari/bafsaZHNw_c/oL04zXszJcgJ Sergey from Moscow wrote on 04/06/2013: Everything was fine at ttp://www.sanskrit-lexicon.uni-koeln.de/cgi-bin/tamil/recherche 2 AbhA 2 f. splendour , light ; a flash ; colour , appearance , beauty MBh. Mn. Sus3r. Pan5cat. &c. ; a reflected image , outline ; likeness , resemblance MBh. R. ; (mfn.) ifc. like , resembling , appearing R. Ka1vya7d. S3is3. &c. (e.g. %{hemA7bha} , shining like gold) ; [cf. Hib. {avibh} , " likeness , similitude "' ; {avibe} ," neatness , elegance "' ; {avibhcal} , `" a spark of fire "' ?] [145,2] In newer (http://www.sanskrit-lexicon.uni-koeln.de/monier/) edition "mfn" is lost, only "f" remains. (H2) A-bhA 2 [L=25230]

funderburkjim commented 10 years ago

OK. The 'mfn' was missing in current database; now corrected.

Interestingly, it was possible to catch within the historical update logs for MW the exact date that the mfn was dropped, 20080512.

A comparison was made between a 2007 version (MONIERhBU.txt) and current monier.xml, looking for similar cases. A few errors surfaced and were corrected; the exact context of this kind of error is difficult to track.

The google group is closed to non-members; its name 'Общество ревнителей санскрита' yields via google.translate the odd English phrase 'Society zealots Sanskrit'.

gasyoun commented 10 years ago

Group is open to everybody with a gmail account. It's my Russian group, which I have started in 2007. It's not odd - it's mine :) 20080512 - great, everything is tracked. How many more? 10? 100?

funderburkjim commented 10 years ago

"How many more? 10? 100?" < 10. I reviewed about 80 possibilities; As I recall, none were exactly like ABA (missing mfn), but I made a few changes in 25 records.

gasyoun commented 9 years ago

Can you upload one day the 80-25 that we would look at as well, please?