sanskrit-lexicon / MWS

Monier Monier-Williams, Sir; A Sanskrit-English dictionary. Oxford, 1899
Other
7 stars 5 forks source link

Gram. 54 Link to Whitney Sanskrit Grammar #159

Closed gasyoun closed 5 months ago

gasyoun commented 11 months ago

@funderburkjim if there would be a one working sample, I could make a list of links to Whitney

gram whitney

Andhrabharati commented 11 months ago

@gasyoun These Grammar citations are from MW's Grammar book, not Whitney's (unless specifically mentioned thus), as I had pointed out recently at another issue (#44), reg. Gr.; the same applies to Gram. as well.

@funderburkjim I see that the tooltip is still showing Whitney at this 'ka' entry; I recall that you had changed the Gr. tooltip; the Gram. tooltip also needs a similar change.

[There are total 10 Gram. citations in MW.]

Andhrabharati commented 11 months ago

BTW, the 'a' after 836 is Roman letter, not Devanagari, here in mw.txt-- <ls>Gram. 836</ls>. <s>a</s> -> <ls>Gram. 836,a.</ls>

image

image

gasyoun commented 11 months ago

These Grammar citations are from MW's Grammar book, not Whitney

That was my first thought as well. @Andhrabharati thanks for noting it once again.

funderburkjim commented 11 months ago

the 'a' after 836 is Roman letter

Corrected.

image

The 'a' appears as 'A' in display due to the charterindocapital font used for text within <ls>Text</ls>.

funderburkjim commented 11 months ago

'Gram.' ls tooltip abbreviation changed to A Practical Grammar of the Sanskrit Language, Monier-Willilams

funderburkjim commented 11 months ago

@gasyoun

File extract.txt has all the (19) instances of <ls>X</ls> where X starts with "Gr." or "Gram.".

Apparently, there is some ambiguity as to whether a given instance of 'Gr.' actually refers to MW's grammar or Whitney's grammar, and similarly for Gram.

You can examine these instances and appropriately replace the question mark with either 'mw' or 'whitney'. For example, based on AB's investigation above under ; <L>41336.1<pc>240,3<k1>ka you would replace

; <L>41336.1<pc>240,3<k1>ka
Gram. 836. a ::: ?

with

Gram. 836. a ::: mw

since Gram. here refers to Monier-Williams Grammar.

Then upload the revised extract.txt file.

You might also note the anomalies where

@gasyoun Please confirm.

Andhrabharati commented 5 months ago

@gasyoun

@funderburkjim's waiting time is nearing 6 months shortly (in another week's time), for this simple task.

funderburkjim commented 5 months ago

I think the above commit finishes what remained to be done.