The confusion is that BaseValidator is not actually the base class of all validators, nor describing the Protocol which custom validators have to satisfy. Instead it seems to be offered as a helpful starting point for defining your own custom validators.
But this means that typing Field.validators: list[BaseValidator] is too specific, because there are validators provided with Django such as RegexValidator which are neither subclass of BaseValidator nor would satisfy its interface if it was treated as a Protocol.
We can see the other django-stubs lib has the more valid type here by defining a simpler _ValidatorCallable alias:
I encountered this issue when trying to use RegexValidator in a custom form field and append it to the field's validators list... pyright in VS Code complains that: "RegexValidator" is incompatible with "BaseValidator"
Here: https://github.com/sbdchd/django-types/blob/main/django-stubs/forms/fields.pyi#L30
The confusion is that
BaseValidatoris not actually the base class of all validators, nor describing the Protocol which custom validators have to satisfy. Instead it seems to be offered as a helpful starting point for defining your own custom validators.But this means that typing
Field.validators: list[BaseValidator]is too specific, because there are validators provided with Django such asRegexValidatorwhich are neither subclass ofBaseValidatornor would satisfy its interface if it was treated as a Protocol.We can see the other django-stubs lib has the more valid type here by defining a simpler
_ValidatorCallablealias:https://github.com/typeddjango/django-stubs/blob/3f9b3c82c3038663beb49fb41c05734eedd95e8b/django-stubs/core/validators.pyi#L15C33-L15C54
https://github.com/typeddjango/django-stubs/blob/3f9b3c82c3038663beb49fb41c05734eedd95e8b/django-stubs/core/validators.pyi#L15C33-L15C54
I encountered this issue when trying to use
RegexValidatorin a custom form field and append it to the field'svalidatorslist... pyright in VS Code complains that:"RegexValidator" is incompatible with "BaseValidator"