search

sc34wg4 / opcRevision

Revision of ISO/IEC 29500-2 (Open Packaging Conventions)
1 stars 0 forks source link

Test justification makes for a visually displeasing appearance #55

Open RexJaeschke opened 4 years ago

RexJaeschke commented 4 years ago

US-088 |   | Annex C |   | Ed | The justified text makes this annex very awkward to read.  The URL for the Media Types stream has been corrupted.  See “UNKNOWN ENTITY” and “blob” in the middle of the URL as displayed as link text.  The link works.

Please revise.

[Rex: This also occurs in some entries in "Normative references" and Annex D.]

RexJaeschke commented 4 years ago

Proposal

I think we have no choice but to set these to left-aligned on a per-case basis, which is subjective and would have to be done manually.

However, see Issue #62. There is no point doing this if ISO's tools will be rerun and justification is enabled on all paragraphs again. We need to ask ISO about this.

murata2makoto commented 4 years ago

ISO's tools will be rerun and justification is enabled on all paragraphs again. ISO will consider justification (and page breaks) only after a new draft is created after the DIS comment disposition.

RexJaeschke commented 4 years ago

Question for ISO: Are we permitted to disable right-justification for those (few) cases? And if so, will the ISO toolchain respect that and not change back to justification right?

ISO: Yes, you can disable right-justification for these cases.

Further question for ISO: Just to be clear, are you saying that manual disabling of justification by us in these cases will be preserved by your tools?

RexJaeschke commented 3 years ago

The file we submit to ISO does not use justification at all! ISO's tools add that. During the post-production stage, we'll have to remind ISO editors to remove justification from Clause 2 (Normative references), Annex C (Schemas - W3C XML), Annex D (Schemas - RELAX NG), and the Bibliography.