BreadcrumbList question

[Adambyb]

Hey guys, i'm trying to add ld+json BreadcrumbList but i'm a bit confused with this case that i havn't found any example about it, I have an item name Product1 it's url "http://example.com/product1"

Product1 has a link in the home page, and another link in the Products page( url "http://example.com/products" ).

whether i clicked on either links of Product1, Product1 url will be same "http://example.com/product1",

Please what could be the right BreadcrumbList for Product1, i Have written the one below but not sure of the position should be 2 or 1 for it in this case,

`

`

[jvandriel]

If I understand you correctly there are 2 breadcrumb paths you can describe:

1. Home > Product 1
2. Home > Products > Product1

Technically both (1) and (2) are just fine, so you can use either or even declare 2 BreadcrumLists to express both paths.

Personally I'd keep it to just (2) though, reason being that I assume it resembles the breadcrumb path for the majority of the products (if not all), thus (most likely) making the implementation a bit more easier.

<script type="application/ld+json">
{
  "@context":"https://schema.org",
  "@type":"BreadcrumbList",
  "itemListElement":
  [
    {
      "@type":"ListItem",
      "position":1,
      "item":
      {
        "@id":"http://example.com/",  
        "name":"Home"
      }
    },{
      "@type":"ListItem",
      "position":2,
      "item":
      {
        "@id":"http://example.com/products/",
        "name":"Products"
      }
    },{
      "@type":"ListItem",
      "position":3,
      "item":
      {
        "@id":"http://example.com/product1/",
        "name":"Product 1"
      }
    }
  ]
}
</script>