scientific-python / changelist

Prepare an automatic changelog from GitHub pull requests
BSD 3-Clause "New" or "Revised" License
8 stars 4 forks source link

Include date of stop revision in generated output #46

Open lagru opened 11 months ago

lagru commented 11 months ago

As recommended in https://keepachangelog.com/en/1.0.0/, release notes or changelogs should contain a date in some form. It's easy enough to include if we settle on what should be the truth. I tend to think it should be the timestamp of the last given revision (stop_rev). This should lead to a correct release date for most cases.

jarrodmillman commented 11 months ago

I would think the date should be the release date (i.e., the date the tag was made). That could be difficult to get right since the changelist is run before tag is made.

Maybe changelist could be extended to handle making the tag as well. If we do that, then it could insert the date at the same. So replace

- Commit changes:

      git add pyproject.toml CHANGELOG.md
      git commit -m "Designate ${VERSION} release"

- Tag the release in git:

      git tag -s v${VERSION} -m "signed ${VERSION} tag"

  If you do not have a gpg key, use -u instead; it is important for
  Debian packaging that the tags are annotated

with

- Commit and tag changes:

      git add pyproject.toml ${CHANGELOG}
      changelist tag ${VERSION} ${CHANGELOG}

where

      changelist tag ${VERSION} ${CHANGELOG}

does something like

      git commit -m "Designate ${VERSION} release"
      # replace a comment in the ${CHANGELOG} with the current date
      git tag -s v${VERSION} -m "signed ${VERSION} tag"
lagru commented 11 months ago

Hmm, the date / tag thing is indeed more tricky than I thought.

I don't think we should expand the scope to creating tags. Right now I like that changelist works entirely on the remote repository with read-access only. Tagging would require to break with that. How about the following solution instead?

jarrodmillman commented 11 months ago

It is hard to predict when you will make a release. So I don't think there is much need for a --date flag. I can just add a note to the release process for projects I am using this for reminding me to manually fix the date when I make the release tag.

Maybe a better solution would be to add a --date flag that would use the date of stop_rev to add a date to the release notes. And if you don't use the flag, then you don't get any date inserted. That would certainly make things easier for me as I could just not include the date.