scryfall / gatherer-bugs

A public repository tracking bugs on gatherer.wizards.com
20 stars 2 forks source link

Collector number search appears to be broken, and does not appear to follow any discernible collector number pattern #131

Open scarletcs opened 2 years ago

scarletcs commented 2 years ago

Collector number search appears to not work at all. Cards do not show up in collector number order. Sometimes they do not appear to show up in any understandable order, with cards just appearing in seemingly random locations. This hampers our ability to actually explore the contents of a set or find cards we're looking for (because we expect them to be, you know, in the order we put things in).

Example searches:

(I invite you to recreate these searches yourself by putting them into advanced search to verify this output.)

In both cases, I would expect card prints to show up in their collector number order. However, this isn't what happens.

In Dominaria United's case, any card with a variant does not show up on the first page. It appears to show up much later, on page 2 or 3, grouped with all its variants, apparently in collector number order based on the last variant available (or that's my best guess, but does not bear out as we'll see later). This has the effect of the cards with collector numbers 1–3 not showing up until the last page of search results:

2022-09-11_14-25-39_firefox

In Dominaria United Commander's case however, the search result ordering just appears insane. Cards 105 and 107 show up first in search order.

2022-09-11_14-29-30_firefox

Later on page 2, we see card 165 appear in order between cards 200 and 201, and card 195 appear in between cards 233 and 234.

2022-09-11_14-30-31_firefox 2022-09-11_14-30-46_firefox

WotC Submission Number: https://magic-support.wizards.com/hc/en-us/requests/2899073

scarletcs commented 2 years ago

One theory is that for DMC, some cards are using their collector numbers as found in other sets. For example:

This might also explain Teshar (DOM 36) and Urza's Ruinous Blast (DOM 39) if these cards are being sorted by highest CN among all variations.

But safe to say search results of DMC's cards should not be getting sorted by DOM's set codes!