search

scummvm / scummvm-icons

Icons repository for ScummVM rich presence
GNU General Public License v2.0
19 stars 22 forks source link

ICONS: Update icon for myst3-myst3 (better crop) #317

Closed beresk-let closed 1 year ago

beresk-let commented 1 year ago

Made the icon more similar to Riven's one in terms of composition. It also resembles the original cover art better now.

tag2015 commented 1 year ago

Hmm, not too sure about this change. The current one is already good IMHO, and has better lettering

Thunderforge commented 1 year ago

I'm not as fond of this change with the thin picture. Also, it kind of looks like, well, 🍆.

If you want a picture that isn't overlapping with the photo, I'd recommend just the house without the tusk.

GandalfTheWhite80 commented 1 year ago

I was also working on a myst3 icon - give a few min. Maybe we could choose the "better fitting" one :-)

GandalfTheWhite80 commented 1 year ago

ah sry for the confusion - updated the myst3 olnyl with a higher res version

https://github.com/scummvm/scummvm-icons/commit/9123ddf6c62e3b167c8f5ff9e8bf61f9d01d1ffd

I sill think that my text is better readable - could you join the discord chanell for a short / easier discussion? I still have the high res image and could crop the lower part according to your idea.

GandalfTheWhite80 commented 1 year ago

@Thunderforge I like your idea about removing the tusk but i'm not shure about the right place of "croping"... made a (in my opintion) slightly better readable version of this request (version 3)

myst3-myst3-v3-ovn

GandalfTheWhite80 commented 1 year ago

Version 4... myst3-myst3-v4

beresk-let commented 1 year ago

@tag2015 thank you for your notes! I do see the difference in lettering, and I do agree that my variant is a bit more blurry (my mistake).

@Thunderforge well, that was a fair point of you as well! And you were correct that my primary intention was to separate the logo and the image, thank you.

@GandalfTheWhite80 several options, very nice, — and thank you as well! I personally like the 4th one the most. The only suggestion I would offer is not to crop the lower (albeit thin) part of the tusk: it could give a visual context and remove the illusion that the house is floating in the air.

GandalfTheWhite80 commented 1 year ago

myst3-myst3-v4a

beresk-let commented 1 year ago

@GandalfTheWhite80 I believe that your version is the definite one to propose now. Thank you for your work! This PR of mine could be dropped now, I guess.

GandalfTheWhite80 commented 1 year ago

Ok - lets drop this pr. I would to mention you as (co)author for the new myst3 icon. Ok?

GandalfTheWhite80 commented 1 year ago

Done: https://github.com/scummvm/scummvm-icons/commit/5e083d5bf7c4a46d5119ea86413602a6acf8de98

beresk-let commented 1 year ago

I appreciate that! But I believe I have not contributed enough to this exact icon to count myself as a coauthor. The stage is all yours!

Thunderforge commented 1 year ago

I'm also in favor of the version from @GandalfTheWhite80. Glad we could reach an agreement on this!