second-state / wasmedge-quickjs

A high-performance, secure, extensible, and OCI-complaint JavaScript runtime for WasmEdge.
Apache License 2.0
477 stars 59 forks source link

Bump quickjs to 2024 #133

Closed L-jasmine closed 7 months ago

juntao commented 7 months ago

Hello, I am a code review bot on flows.network. Here are my reviews of code commits in this PR.


Overall Summary: In the GitHub Pull Request titled "Bump quickjs to 2024", there are several important findings and potential issues that need to be addressed.

First, there are dependency updates, including a changed checksum for the base64 crate. This may introduce compatibility issues or bugs, so it is crucial to review the changes in the base64 crate to ensure it won't cause any problems. Additionally, the updates to several dependencies may introduce compatibility issues or breaking changes, so it's important to review the changelogs or release notes for each dependency.

Next, there are changes related to the development environment setup. The removal of the .devcontainer/devcontainer.json file may have unintended consequences, so it's necessary to understand the reason behind this change and ensure that it does not impact the project. Furthermore, the use of sudo in the command for installing WasmEdge should be reviewed to ensure it is necessary and doesn't introduce security risks. Additionally, the URL for downloading the WasmEdge-plugin-wasmedge_rustls tarball is not updated to reflect the new version.

There are also changes related to the addition of new files and directories, such as ggml_chat.js and ggml/mod.rs. These changes don't seem to have any potential problems.

Furthermore, there are changes made to specific code files, such as src/internal_module/httpx/js_module.rs and a fix for the promise_loop_poll function in the Context struct. These changes require further testing and clarification to ensure their correctness and understand their purpose.

Finally, there is a fix for an issue with the process.argv variable, but the introduction of globalThis.args without sufficient context raises concerns about potential problems it may cause.

In summary, this pull request introduces several important changes and potential issues that need to be addressed. It's crucial to review the changes in base64 crate, dependency updates, development environment setup, specific code modifications, and the introduction of globalThis.args. Clarifications and further testing are needed to ensure the correctness and impact of the proposed changes.

Details

Commit d8e70af5bc103e448da01d4608d14332a4183a62

The key changes in this patch are:

Potential problems to note:

Commit 7ca0db86c34c09304243836ebaaeee1f8b9d91d8

Key changes in the patch:

  1. The file .devcontainer/devcontainer.json is deleted.
  2. In the file .github/workflows/examples.yml, the WasmEdge version is bumped from 0.13.4 to 0.13.5. The command for installing WasmEdge is also modified to include the plugins wasi_nn-tensorflowlite and wasi_crypto.

Potential problems:

  1. Removing the .devcontainer/devcontainer.json file may have unintended consequences for the development environment setup. It would be good to understand the reason behind this change and ensure that it does not impact the project.
  2. The use of sudo in the command for installing WasmEdge (curl -sSf https://raw.githubusercontent.com/WasmEdge/WasmEdge/master/utils/install.sh | sudo bash -s -- -e all --version=$VERSION --plugins wasi_nn-tensorflowlite wasi_crypto -p /usr/local) should be reviewed to ensure it is necessary and does not introduce security risks.
  3. The URL for downloading the WasmEdge-plugin-wasmedge_rustls tarball is not updated to reflect the new version ($VERSION should be replaced with 0.13.5).

These are the most important findings and potential issues in the patch.

Commit 6d0be6d33d978ca83d037754a4e45a9380c9b082

The key changes in this patch include:

In ggml_chat.js:

In ggml/mod.rs:

There don't appear to be any potential problems with these changes.

Commit cb444fef94d90737619b293f89427776d3d0a096

Key changes:

Potential problems:

Overall, the change appears to be a fix for the js_get_method method, ensuring that the self.method value is properly converted to a string. However, further testing may be needed to ensure that the conversion works as expected in all scenarios.

Commit c39f8e3b6503e7d1c0e76f534fcf5aa826265641

Key Changes:

Potential Problems:

Overall, it is important to address the potential problems and clarify the intentions behind the changes made in this patch.

Commit 17128409cda50459b4559f559c98a736233dfb25

Key changes:

Potential problems:

Overall, the patch seems to address a specific issue and makes a minor change to the process.js file. However, the introduction of globalThis.args without sufficient context raises doubts about the potential problems it may cause.