OTP component - can't focus and edit inputs others than the last one

[T3sT3ro]

1. See the demo of the OTP field
2. enter 123456
3. try to click/shift-tab the input with "3" to correct it to 0
4. You can't, only backspace is allowed

The OTP field should support fixing mistakes and editing individual inputs

[sek-consulting]

It behaves the same as the underlying corvu component: https://corvu.dev/docs/primitives/otp-field/

But feel free to open an issue over there if you think the behavior should be fixed. :)

[T3sT3ro]

The same issue is present on the Shadcn repo and it's marked as bug. I assume the components behavior here should be modeled primarily based on the shadcn, and although the same behavior is present in the corvu repo, in my opinion it should be only secondary, and the responsibility lies in this repo as well for the following two reasons:

• using corvu is the implementation detail chosen by this repo, as far as my expectations go it should "behave like it does/is intended to work by original shadcn"
• influences (negatively) the user experience when using this library

I will report on corvu's website as well, but because it's not what I use, but what this repo uses under the hood, I chose this place to be more appropiate.

[sek-consulting]

The primitive dictates the behavior of the component (at least for the most part).

It's correct that SolidUI is inspired and mostly a direct port of shadcn-ui but it's using kobalte & corvu as the underlying layers. And since there are some differences in design decisions (in comparision to RadixUI) those are reflected in SolidUI.

A prime example would be having a TextField component instead of a separate Input, TextArea, Input one (even though I kept Input).

I know that might be confusing for people how come over from shadcn-ui but it makes it much easier if you're looking for information if you want to change something, since you can just follow the docs of the primitives.