semanticarts / gist

Semantic Arts gist upper enterprise ontology
Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International
163 stars 18 forks source link

Text definition of contributesTo is too narrow. #572

Open uscholdm opened 3 years ago

uscholdm commented 3 years ago

In English, the meaning of 'contributes to' is very broad. So it would be sensible to say that a degree in computer science contributes to a person developing programming skills. The text definition of contributesTo is:

If you say a degree in computer science contributes to a person developing programming skills, there are no parts of any system per se, so it does not align with the text definition of contributes to.

I’m saying that the definition of contributesTo is too narrowly focused on system-think, which is historical due to its origin in the network sub-gist.

PROPOSAL:

ALTERNATIVE:

rjyounes commented 3 years ago

I agree with broadening the definition of contributesTo. I think of examples as being more specific - individual cases - so I would just toss the current definition altogether.

rjyounes commented 3 years ago

This is subsumed by #534 but I'll leave it open so we make sure to take these points into consideration.

jtdelany58 commented 1 year ago

@uscholdm Something that has a share in bringing about a result.</skos:definition>

Example1: The parts of a system contribute to the goal/ function of the whole system. Example 2: Fructose contributes to obesity in some people.