search

serverless / compose

Orchestrate Serverless Framework in monorepos
https://serverless.com/framework/docs/guides/compose
MIT License
111 stars 15 forks source link

"--param" option is not supported #111

Open chkrause opened 2 years ago

chkrause commented 2 years ago

Unfortunatly I can't pass param to the serverless compose. serverless deploy --stage del --param="AccountIdZendesk=xxxxxxx"

Cannot resolve variable at "custom.AccountIdZendesk": The param "AccountIdZendesk" cannot be resolved from CLI options or stage params. If you are using Serverless Framework Compose, make sure to run commands via Compose so that all parameters can be resolved

The "--param" option is not supported (yet) in Serverless Framework Compose

I have currently 2 serverless projects depending on each other. One of the projects requires a parameter that has to be defined at deployment time.

mnapoli commented 2 years ago

Thanks for opening this. At the moment (as you experienced) it's not possible with Compose to pass parameters with CLI options, or define stage parameters in YAML config.

It's probably something we want to support eventually though, so let's keep this issue open 👍

semiautomatixfu commented 2 years ago

The issue is that you can not longer use serverless package --service service-b as a result because params would be undefined is not passed from another service.

pgrzesik commented 2 years ago

Could you clarify @semiautomatixfu? The params should still be passed, but --param CLI option is not supported on Compose level

semiautomatixfu commented 2 years ago

@pgrzesik I'm referencing this issue https://github.com/serverless/compose/issues/148

cmcnicholas commented 1 year ago

is there any major blocker here just supporting passthrough for cli args that aren't supported 1st class by compose? it seems that the additional comments raised that cause concern are more about specialised usage of compose, I'd simply like to define core env variables to provide consistently across deployment during a CD pipeline.

Kayyow commented 1 year ago

Any update on this feature request ?

sadashiv-sumasoft commented 11 months ago

Hello any update on this feature?

akordzik commented 8 months ago

Hi @mnapoli , is anyone looking at this feature?

trykovyura commented 8 months ago

Yes - it will be very usefull

Maybe you know workarounds to pass params on deploy? Because do not wont to hard code it in serverless.yml

mnapoli commented 8 months ago

@akordzik I no longer work at Serverless Inc. so I cannot answer that.