sfg-taxonpages / orthoptera

0 stars 0 forks source link

As a community we would like to know the best-practices for archiving OSF #62

Open mjy opened 6 months ago

mjy commented 6 months ago

OSF is seeking to provide an example of best-practices defined by the COL. One of those best-practices is "archving".

The two targets for archiving I feel we should pursue first, in order, are

Additional exploration could target GItHub's policy on archiving.

Can we

Once the archive is live

debpaul commented 6 months ago

Just starting to delve.

Zenodo FAQ has some information on metadata requirements and standards, for example.

COL archiving.

  1. See COL Archive Repository
  2. note that trying to access and understand a COL archive, the downloads I tried, failed.

From GitHub see Referencing and citing content

To make your repositories easier to reference in academic literature, you can create persistent identifiers, also known as Digital Object Identifiers (DOIs). You can use the data archiving tool Zenodo to archive a repository on GitHub.com and issue a DOI for the archive. Zenodo archives your repository and issues a new DOI each time you create a new GitHub release. Follow the steps at "Managing releases in a repository" to create a new one.

MMCigliano commented 6 months ago

If downloads from COL Archive Repository works, maybe this would be the natural repository. We could export to ChecklistBank in a more frequent period (4 times a year)

debpaul commented 6 months ago

If downloads from COL Archive Repository works, maybe this would be the natural repository. We could export to ChecklistBank in a more frequent period (4 times a year)

@MMCigliano I don't know (since it didn't work). I can't see what it contains.

Also, considering points made by @mjy about connecting "the data" and "the web pages" we need to see what's inside the COL to judge if it might work. For example, I can't see "the metadata" included in the COL file. More research needed. I'll be posting a ticket to the COL github repo to see if Markus Doering can fix the download.

debpaul commented 6 months ago

Update @mjy @MMCigliano for some reason (unknown to me): download of COL archives works for Geoff, fails on my computer. So you might both try (so we can "see" what's in them). And I'll suss out more later, why not working for me.

klausriede commented 2 months ago

redundancy in data storage and archiving is always good. However, just a reminder that OSF exceeds Zenodo and COL by far, reaching back to the 1990s when Daniel Otte started to establish a digital list of types and references. I think that this supremacy in data continuity should be maintained. It might be complemented by strategies of offline longterm digital storage.