Open shaunlxw opened 4 months ago
The error message is indeed correct, because a blank is not alphanumeric. It is also further stated in our UG that the TAG
should only contain alphanumeric characters and spaces.
Severity Low
because it only appears in very rare situations when users try to input blank tags.
Team chose [response.Rejected
]
Reason for disagreement: In the UG, the below is stated for edit command.
This means blank tags are allowed, as can also be tested by the command edit 1 t/
that succeeds. This means the above two commands given should either succeed, or should output an error message specifying "No other tag parameters should be entered after a blank tag parameter t/
". The blank tag is intentional by the user in an attempt to remove all the student's tags, and the issue lies with specifying additional tag fields along with the blank tag (that isn't disallowed according to the UG). The error message is not accurate since it does not address the issue of the additional tag fields given with the blank tag.
Hence it is a bug since the UG specifically mentioned that this can be done, and error message on failure doesn't specify accurately what is wrong with the above mentioned commands.
Input: