shosetsuorg / shosetsu

An android application for reading light novels. Moved to https://gitlab.com/shosetsuorg/shosetsu
https://shosetsu.app
GNU General Public License v3.0
581 stars 34 forks source link

[Bug] [2186]Wrong chapter resumed after Resume button is clicked #209

Open Palloxin opened 2 years ago

Palloxin commented 2 years ago

Describe the bug When i fully read a chapter until the end without going to the next chapter, i exit the app and then come back. once i click the resume button the app resume the next chapter of the last one i read and i don't want it. i want that the app resumes where i left, doesn't matter if i scrolled the full chapter until the bottom. Why? scrolling the full.chapter doesn't mean i read until the end of the chapter so i might have left or closed the app so i want the resume button to bring me there and not to the next chapter

To Reproduce Steps to reproduce the behavior:

  1. Fully read a chapter until the buttom
  2. come back and then click tge resume button

Expected behavior the app should resume the point where i left and not the next chapter

Screenshots If applicable, add screenshots to help explain your problem.

Device information:

Additional context setting Marking metod: On view scrolled

Doomsdayrs commented 2 years ago

Shosetsu does not have the capability to read your eye movement, It assumes that by scrolling to the bottom of a chapter you have marked it as read.

Regardless on how you feel about this, I do not see it as wise to introduce complicated mechanisms to monitor user behavior to figure out if they actually read the entire chapter or not.

Palloxin commented 2 years ago

Shosetsu does not have the capability to read your eye movement, It assumes that by scrolling to the bottom of a chapter you have marked it as read.

Regardless on how you feel about this, I do not see it as wise to introduce complicated mechanisms to monitor user behavior to figure out if they actually read the entire chapter or not.

what about adding another option that change the behaviour based on this report? also the word "resume" means you come back exactly where i left like in a game, not the next level. if you pause a game when you are at the end of the level and then come back, would you like that level being completed automatically when pressing "resume" and jump to the next level? maybe you want to explore it more before jumping to the next level idk, that is the players business to do so. the app just assumes i read that fully so just to be safe if the user didn't swap to the next chapter don't make the app do it automatically when resuming with the button. @Doomsdayrs

Palloxin commented 2 years ago

also, if the swap between chapters was continuous with no 'hardship' it wouldn't be a problem at all, just saying.