shyaamald / pe

0 stars 0 forks source link

Unable to delete/edit incorrect orders #5

Open shyaamald opened 1 week ago

shyaamald commented 1 week ago

image.png

There is no way to deal with orders that may have mistakes in them, as there are only three order management functions: order, fulfill-order and view-orders (no delete or edit).

As such, the only way to clear an incorrect order from the order list is to fulfill it.

nus-pe-bot commented 4 days ago

Team's Response

As of v2.1, there is no functionality to edit, delete, or save orders. This limitation means users must rely on workarounds to address errors or manage orders. Specifically, users can leave an incorrect order unfulfilled and create a new order with the correct details. Alternatively, since orders are not saved to the hard disk, users can restart the application to clear all orders.

While these workarounds may not be ideal, they allow users to continue using the application without significant disruption. It is important to note that the second workaround should only be used after fulfilling all valid orders, as restarting the application results in the loss of all order data.

Given the availability of these workarounds, the impact on usability is minimal, and the issue does not affect the application's core functionality. Consequently, the severity has been downgraded to low.

Items for the Tester to Verify

:question: Issue severity

Team chose [severity.Low] Originally [severity.Medium]

Reason for disagreement: This is a flaw that is likely to affect normal operations of the product, and it can appear fairly often as mistakes in filling out orders can be made. This would also cause more than just a minor inconvenience, since the workarounds are to just make a new order or to restart the application, which are quite tedious.

This is why the level of severity of this issue should be a medium rather than a low.