search

sig-cm / ASIST-2020

Repository for ASIST 2020 workshop
1 stars 0 forks source link

Wickett - Review #5

Open nniiicc opened 4 years ago

nniiicc commented 4 years ago

Wickett Paper

Relevance to workshop (1-5): Potential for JASIST submission (1-5): Decision (Accept, Reject, Lightning talk):

Feedback to authors:

nniiicc commented 4 years ago

Feedback to authors:

The general goals are clear, but some concrete applications - such as the consequence of not having a BRM would be helpful for the casual reader. More generally, I'd encourage use cases which extend beyond cultural heritage and scientific data - What kinds of other born digital objects would benefit from being modeled with BRM?

kfenlon commented 4 years ago

This paper would be a good fit for the workshop/proposed JASIS&T issue. The paper raises cross-cutting problems in conceptual modeling, which readily translate into pragmatic problems in functioning systems. Hearing more about these pragmatic problems will help ground the theoretical discussion; perhaps this was already in your plans, but I suggest raising a compelling example or two in the introduction (perhaps ones you'll expand in 4.2) to motivate the paper and ground and anticipate your critiques in section 2 or 4. I am interested in learning more about how the BRM can help support connections between info organization, info management, and digital preservation, and what "connections" in this context means. The paper will provoke interesting and valuable discussion about the mappings/relationships among entities in various models. For example, other than the fact that one is constrained by its application in an OAIS, what's the relationship between interpretive frames and representation information?