signalapp / Signal-Android

A private messenger for Android.
https://signal.org
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
25.62k stars 6.15k forks source link

Please support sending stickers #5445

Closed rbalint closed 6 years ago

rbalint commented 8 years ago

I have:


Bug description

Users can't send stickers to each other using Signal. This is a deal breaker for some users preventing switching to Signal from other messenger apps such as Viber.

Adding a sticker store may also help funding the project.

Screenshots

screen-shot-2013-04-16-at-10 57 46-am1 Ths screenshots are copied from here: http://www.adweek.com/socialtimes/facebook-updates-iphone-app-with-stickers-and-chat-heads-ipad-gets-new-design/292460

rhetr commented 8 years ago

some info on foss sticker implementations:

https://wiki.tox.chat/developers/feature_ideas/stickers https://github.com/qTox/qTox/issues/402 https://github.com/irungentoo/toxcore/issues/1106 https://github.com/Gargron/xmpp-web/issues/3

there are a number of telegram stickers, maybe it's possible to use them https://www.stickerstelegram.com/ http://telegramhub.net/

Fnatte79 commented 8 years ago

I agree, it is a deal breaker for many. For time being I use both Telegram and Signal but still have a few friends who not seems to wanna change to Signal just because it doesn't support stickers.

hermannsblum commented 8 years ago

push I find this THE dealbraker when trying to convince people to switch from telegram to signal.

nrizzio commented 8 years ago

This has been implemented in 69d0242574cc68b068afe3a00861e574b176f08b (Giphy support), so this issue should be closed.

2-4601 commented 7 years ago

Is the Stickers tab in the Giphy browser the same as the sticker feature requested in this issue? I have really no idea... :thinking:

rbalint commented 7 years ago

Thanks for improving Signal, Giphy support is indeed a related addition. I think to claim this case resolved Signal needs a more user friendly method of sending ''stickers' and on the receiver side the sticker should not be in a bounding box rectangle because it is less nice than Viber's solution. I also tried sending PNG-s with alpha background and only a black box is shown in the conversation.

nrizzio commented 7 years ago

Fixed by 1b44bdc (for sure!)

2-4601 commented 7 years ago

I think the original feature request is about adding a drawer for stickers (like the emojis have) and then attaching them directly to the conversation as messages (without the message bubble around them). This is different from the scribble mode where you can add stickers on existing image attachments. But at least there are sticker resources now :)

rbalint commented 7 years ago

When I opened the bug I meant making Signal able to send and receive stickers and creating a user experience on par with Messenger/Viber regarding this feature. I have not tried 1b44bdc yet, thus I can't tell if both parts are done. I'm OK with closing this bug even if it is only possible but not user friendly to send stickers, I can open a new one for making it easy.

rbalint commented 7 years ago

Thank you for working on this feature BTW!

2-4601 commented 7 years ago

@rbalint 1b44bdc is in 3.25.3 which is available in the Google Play release.

rbalint commented 7 years ago

@2-4601 @nrizzio I have tried 3.25.4 and yes, I the thing implemented is different from what I asked and provided screenshots for. I suggest reopening this issue but thank you for the implemented scribble mode, this can be useful for some people, too.

tajnymag commented 7 years ago

Awesome feature would be to create your own packs. That way Whisper Systems wouldn't have to come up with their own unique stickers packs. I'm pretty sure there would be enough users crowdsourcing stickers 😄

rocurley commented 7 years ago

Not the op, but IMO the spec for Tox would likely do it. Telegram has a pretty thriving ecosystem of stickers based on this model.

ghost commented 6 years ago

Any updates ?

deutrino commented 6 years ago

@rocurley or anyone - are there links to creative commons / open source / libre sticker packs using that or any standard spec?

automated-signal commented 6 years ago

GitHub Issue Cleanup: See #7598 for more information.

alan-signal commented 4 years ago

https://signal.org/blog/make-privacy-stick/