Override Do Not Disturb doesn't work for Calls.

[ghost]

• [x ] I have searched open and closed issues for duplicates
• [x ] I am submitting a bug report for existing functionality that does not work as intended
• [ x] I have read https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/wiki/Submitting-useful-bug-reports
• [ x] This isn't a feature request or a discussion topic

---

Bug description

Override Do Not Disturb doesn't work for calls. No vibration during call. For messages everything work fine.

Steps to reproduce

• enable Do Not Disturb in Priority Only mode
• enable Override Do Not Disturb for Signal Calls notification
• Receive a call

Actual result: Call starts, but without vibration or sound. Expected result: Call starts with vibration and sound.

Screenshots

Device info

Device: Xiaomi Redmi Note 4x Android version: 9.0 Signal version: 4.52.4

Link to debug log

https://debuglogs.org/9996396016ef7a34575215d7cc783c8ed788614b0cdb927ae9a48a4fca91015f

[longspell]

I having the same issue, enabling "override do not disturb" does not work, when phone is set to ring there is no ring and when set to vibrate there is no vibration.

Signal 5.3.10 Pixel 4 XL Android 11

Debug logs: https://debuglogs.org/9035130bdcfa52a19ffe8e6cbbc8583c9d4e2631f03e1fa0b4a7ab5e1351c42f

[fschlatt]

Same issue, exceptions for messages and calls are activated in the do not disturb settings. Messages vibrate, calls completely silent. With do not disturb off calls work fine.

Signal 5.14.5 Pixel 4 Android 11

[stale[bot]]

Is this still relevant? If so, what is blocking it? Is there anything you can do to help move it forward?

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs.

[longspell]

This is still revelant. Setting the calls notification to override Do Not Disturb doesn't work and the notification is is silent. Disabling DND the notification comes in with the configured sound.

Pixel 6 Pro, android 12, January update (build SQ1D.220105.007)

[mboruta1]

Encountering the same issue with Signal 5.30.6 on an LG v20 running 8.0.0.

[stale[bot]]

This issue has been automatically marked as stale because it has not had recent activity. It will be closed if no further activity occurs. Thank you for your contributions.

[longspell]

Can confirm this is still happening. Noticed today when do not disturb is disabled that the ring tone selected in system notification settings is not the one that plays, there is a separate configuration in the app with another sound for calls that is played.

Pixel 6 Pro on Android 12 (5 April security patch), signal version 5.35.3.

[tobiscode]

Happening here as well, Pixel 6, Android 12, (5 April security, 1 January Google Play updates), Signal 5.40.4 (although this hasn't worked for me at anytime in the past that I remember).

[holocronweaver]

Affecting me as well.

Device: Pixel 4 XL Android: 12; June 5, 2022 (also did not work on 11 iirc) Signal: 5.40.4

As others mentioned, Signal message notifications can get through if permitted under Android DoNotDisturb, but not call notifications. Have tried both allow all call notifications in DND settings as well as allowing "highlighted conversations" (all of which Signal conversations), neither allowed incoming call notifications.

This should be a high priority item, regularly results in missed calls on Android for anyone who uses DND (e.g., most working people and activists with Android phones).

[samsapti]

When can we expect this to be fixed?

[tobiscode]

Since it just happened to me again, here's a debug log: https://debuglogs.org/android/5.49.4/4d297599a938df770cdcf9bd0a9cc99db1a2b8ddcb49723ce525a5085df4198a

[voxelv]

I've only ever had this issue. It's not intermittent.

[medakk]

Happens to me all of the time, but it vibrates once (doesn't ring) when I receive a call

Signal 6.5.6, Pixel 6a with Android 13 Dec 2022 update

[cody-signal]

Hi folks, the reason for this is we don't use the notification to play the ringtone or vibrate. We do it manually. We have to do this so we can play different ringtones for different callers.

We've talked about changing this behavior and essentially creating call channels for every contact you customize but it's not something we have scheduled to work on. However, given this and other issues we've encountered recently we may have to go that route.

[samsapti]

@cody-signal AFAIK that's the way the AOSP SMS app does it when you customize notifications for a contact, so that sounds like a sensible idea. Thanks for working on this!

[graywolf-at-work]

Is there some workaround in the mean time? Even if I allow all notification times for the Signal app, it still does not ring. Is the only option currently to turn off the DND mode?

[AmirGamilDev]

Same here.

Device: Samsung Galaxy A52s 5G Android version: 13 Signal version: 6.13.7

Other apps seem to handle it well. Google Meet works exactly as expected accounting for contacts only/favourites only and repeat callers. WhatsApp handles it less well then Meet but still not bad. Would love to see Signal handle this the best 😉

[tobiscode]

Cross-referencing this post: https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/issues/7733#issuecomment-1529811508

@nicholas-signal @cody-signal how will dropping the telecom component affect this issue? Can we hope that dropping telecom will free up resources to address the DND malfunction?

[tobiscode]

Any update on this?

(I can't believe how old this issue is - does it just not affect everyone or is my use case that niche?)

[graywolf-at-work]

Any update on this?

(I can't believe how old this issue is - does it just not affect everyone or is my use case that niche?)

If nothing else, I am affected as well, but based on an age of this issue, I somehow think that pinging "me too" here will do no good anyway, so I just suffer in silence.

But the suffering is decreasing over time, since people learned to not call me over signal (since I do not pick up due to this bug), but instead via the regular phone call. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[AmirGamilDev]

Still happening for me too. Other apps seem to handle it okay. Perhaps a similar approach could be done?

[silly-rabbit-tricks]

If nothing else, I am affected as well, but based on an age of this issue, I somehow think that pinging "me too" here will do no good anyway, so I just suffer in silence.

A bit dramatic, but I like it. For what it's worth, I'm also anxiously waiting for this to be fixed.

[holocronweaver]

@cody-signal If it comes down to ringtone per contact vs. not missing a call, I hope reliability triumphs over aesthetic. For a communication app, reliability should be priority 1.

[silly-rabbit-tricks]

If I'm understanding correctly, if Signal were to use Android system notification channels, then Signal contacts would still have custom ringtones based off the system contacts.

True, you couldn't set custom, Signal specific tones, but contacts would still have their own tones based off their system contact settings. Seems more streamlined doing it that way anyways not to mention having DND work properly...

[maxonb]

Im having the same issue.

It seems that signal app is checking dnd settings and then in addition to this checks ringer mode which is set to silence automatically if dnd is enabled (due to weird android api design). This blocks the ring sound and vibration.

Phone: Samsung s22+ Android version: 13 Signal version: 6.26.4

[maxonb]

Hi folks, the reason for this is we don't use the notification to play the ringtone or vibrate. We do it manually. We have to do this so we can play different ringtones for different callers.

We've talked about changing this behavior and essentially creating call channels for every contact you customize but it's not something we have scheduled to work on. However, given this and other issues we've encountered recently we may have to go that route.

It seems that NotificationManagerCompat supports displaying notifications with custom individual sounds. It maybe an alternative solution to per contact channels.

[cody-signal]

Hi folks, still on our radar, made a note to chat about this at our next sync session.

[silly-rabbit-tricks]

Do forgive our (or maybe just my) impatience... are there any updates here? :-)

Edit: Actually asking about a 3.5+ year old issue may not qualify as impatience.... maybe. (Mild humor - but seriously, thank you for all the work you guys put in to this project.)

[cody-signal]

No update, still on our radar.

[amrbekhit]

Hi, just wanted to confirm this is still an issue. Running Signal 6.42.3 on Android 13.

[voxelv]

The failure to fix this issue for 4 years leads me to believe Signal is less than "fun, dependable, and available to everyone."

[AmirGamilDev]

Better than WhatsApp. It doesn't respect DND setting and there's no option to do anything about it! Annoying in a different way.

I agree this bug deserves some attention though.

---

Sent from my phone. Please excuse typos.

On Tue 5 Mar 2024, 06:43 voxelv, @.***> wrote:

The failure to fix this issue for 4 years leads me to believe Signal is less than "fun, dependable, and available to everyone."

— Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/signalapp/Signal-Android/issues/9297#issuecomment-1978064595, or unsubscribe https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ALOUG5M7KB2ZH6I62PO2V5DYWVSP3AVCNFSM4J6KS3X2U5DIOJSWCZC7NNSXTN2JONZXKZKDN5WW2ZLOOQ5TCOJXHAYDMNBVHE2Q . You are receiving this because you commented.Message ID: @.***>

[tobiscode]

Well I didn't think I'd get to this topic in this way but here we are: Now I've experienced two situations where with DND on and Signal not in the list of approved exceptions, I've got calls ringing loudly. Did anything change in the codebase that shifted this behavior? I didn't see anything mentioned in the changelogs but obviously this is just as wrong than the original behavior...

If I remember correctly, Signal uses some sort of media player API for calls - if that is for ringing as well, maybe it went through DND because Android thought it was a media sound like from a game or video? I might have time to test this hypothesis in the coming days but wanted to check in here first in case there were changes I missed.

[Nojevah]

I've just experimented that strange behavior. With DND enabled and no exception, phone ringed loudly and screen stayed off. Super weird situation. First time I had an app not respecting DND. Only "Alarms" and "Media sound" are authorized, so I guess Signal used one of these ("Alarms" I guess), without waking screen, so strange.