signalapp / Signal-iOS

A private messenger for iOS.
https://signal.org
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
10.83k stars 3.04k forks source link

I am no longer receiving notification from signal app IOS 15 #5148

Closed prbryandr closed 1 year ago

prbryandr commented 3 years ago

Bug description

Describe here the issue that you are experiencing.

Steps to reproduce

Actual result: Describe here what happens after you run the steps above (i.e. the buggy behaviour)

Expected result: Describe here what should happen after you run the steps above (i.e. what would be the correct behaviour)

Screenshots

Device info

Device: iDevice X

iOS version: X.Y.Z

Signal version: Z.Y

Link to debug log

krnkris commented 3 years ago

Same issue:

iPhone Xs Max

IOS 15.0

Signal 5.21.1

Issue:

If I receive message no longer receiving notification from signal app IOS 15.

Tried reload + switch off / on + register push notification Nothing helps.

TACIXAT commented 3 years ago

Same issue.

annalisabarla commented 3 years ago

Updated to 5.21.2 iOS 15 iPhone 12 Pro

still having the same issue

akm-hawk commented 3 years ago

Updated: Also with iOS 15.1 the issue persists with same Signal version.

Original issue:

iPhone 12 Pro Max

IOS 15.0

Signal version: 5.21.2.4

Issue:

If I receive a message it does not send a notification unless the app is open, not even if iPhone is unlocked, only when accessing the app. It also does not come across as delivered from the recipient's POV.

Tried to reload + switch off / on + register push notification and a complete delete and redownload of the app.

Nothing helps and no notifications is coming through unless I open the app.

Uolsen commented 3 years ago

I had the same issue with iOS 15 but now it looks it works again (after update to iOS 15.0.1, signal 5.21.2.5 beta ).

Edit: No, sorry, still no change. It will be great if I will have opportunity to reinstall. But I don't want to lose all my messages. Why Signal still don't have support for exporting to file like on Android?

Tobst3r commented 3 years ago

Same issue:

iPhone 12 & iPhone 13 Pro Max

iOS 15.0 and iOS 15.1

Signal 5.21.2.4

Issue:

Not receiving push notifications on my device. Deleted all linked accounts and reinstalled Signal on my iPhone. Issue seems to happen after the app has been closed for a few minutes. Tried reload + switch off / on + register push notification Nothing helps. Even upgrading the phone from iPhone 12 to the new 13 Pro Max didn’t solve the problem.

If helpful i can provide the Signal debug files via a private channel.

charlesmchen-signal commented 3 years ago

@Tobst3r @Uolsen @akm-hawk @annalisabarla etc.

Please update to 5.21.2 or later (5.21.3 is in the works) if you haven't already. If you notice any missing notifications, please send debug logs to ios-beta@signal.org Thank you!

Instructions for sending debug logs can be found here: https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007318591-Debug-Logs-and-Crash-Reports

Tobst3r commented 3 years ago

@Tobst3r @Uolsen @akm-hawk @annalisabarla etc.

Please update to 5.21.2 or later (5.21.3 is in the works) if you haven't already. If you notice any missing notifications, please send debug logs to ios-beta@signal.org Thank you!

Instructions for sending debug logs can be found here: https://support.signal.org/hc/en-us/articles/360007318591-Debug-Logs-and-Crash-Reports

Thanks for your reply! I’m already on 5.21.2.4 and still had issues today. I will send you the debug logs

krnkris commented 3 years ago

Now is suddenly begin to work again:

IOS 15.0 & updated to 15.0.1

Signal 5.21.1 then upgraded to 5.21.2.4 version change did not helped.


As of today it works again may be the messaging center/system caused the problem.

From my side the issue is closed. Thank you developers!

annalisabarla commented 3 years ago

Everything updated as recommended, issue is still there. Sending logs Thanks for your reply

Tobst3r commented 3 years ago

As of today I have noticed that I only get notifications from one of my signal contacts, the other ones only appear when I open the app.

Still on iPhone 13 Pro Max - 5.21.2.4

Antoine2tt commented 3 years ago

Same here, if the app is close, no notification

When i open the app, notifications are shown

Signal 5.21.2.4 / iOS 15.0.1

krnkris commented 3 years ago

Now is suddenly not working again.

IOS 15.0.1

Signal 5.21.2.4

Really don't understand this , yesterday half day worked as usually.

dominikwilkowski commented 3 years ago

No notifications at all under iOS 15. Signal 5.21.3.6.

antolonappan commented 3 years ago

Are you guys sure that you have set the Settings>Notifications>Schedule summary is on? And set Settings>Notifications>Signal>Immediate delivery

Tobst3r commented 3 years ago

Are you guys sure that you have set the Settings>Notifications>Schedule summary is on? And set Settings>Notifications>Signal>Immediate delivery

Notifications in iOS are configured correctly. I am getting push notifications from some of my signal contacts but some never show notifications. Don't see how iOS could be at fault here

Uolsen commented 3 years ago

Are you guys sure that you have set the Settings>Notifications>Schedule summary is on? And set Settings>Notifications>Signal>Immediate delivery

I don't event have Schedule summary on. Still no notifications

dominikwilkowski commented 3 years ago

Are you guys sure that you have set the Settings>Notifications>Schedule summary is on? And set Settings>Notifications>Signal>Immediate delivery

Same here. Notifications enabled, batch disabled, no new notification unless the app is on and in the foreground and even then not consistently

Uolsen commented 3 years ago

Strangely for me they are now working. I will update if anything will change

krnkris commented 3 years ago

@Uolsen

Interesting! Could you please tell us IOS version and Signal version -

krnkris commented 3 years ago

Now it works: IPHONE Xs max Ios 15.0.1 Signal: 5.21.4.6

Thank you developers!

annalisabarla commented 3 years ago

Now it’s working again

iPhone 12 Pro iOS 15.1 signal 5.21.4.6

akm-hawk commented 3 years ago

Hereby fixed on 5.21.4.6 in iOS 15.0.1 running iPhone 12 Pro Max

Awesome job 🙌

nyejon commented 3 years ago

I still have this issue.

iPhone 8, iOS 15.0.1 Signal 5.21.4.6

nickcharles commented 3 years ago

I'm also seeing this issue on an iPhone SE 1st Gen, iOS 15.0.2, Signal 5.21.4.6.

Every now and then I'll get a notification while the app is closed, but otherwise all notifications only show up once I open the app.

Just enabled debug logging, will submit debug logs in 24 hours.

Octocitrus commented 3 years ago

Phone: iphone xr Ios: 15.1 (19B74) Signal: 5.23.0.38

Issue: After Updating to ios 15, the app stopped receiving Messages till opened. Went thru all Settings, renewed Push Notification Registration, Focus Mode off, No Battery Saving, No Message Batching, ... . Cant reinstall because theres no way to keep my messages.

Signal App on Ipad still works as intended.

Ramadel commented 3 years ago

Exact same problems for me.

iPhone 8 Plus iOS 15.0.2

All notifications are set up correctly. Signal simply doesn't come through most of the time. I have to open the app, then suddenly I have a bunch of messages waiting for me. About to scrap Signal for any important communications.

Octocitrus commented 3 years ago

Here's my current debug log. The issue remains, still no notifications. :(

https://debuglogs.org/dfc134b3bfca21e844f3719c852f5462f464b8ee7725f5fcbd16cd7e8f8c0468.zip

Octocitrus commented 3 years ago

I've since watched the behavior and it seems to be the case that pushes are coming through a few hours later. How can one get some reaction to this?

Debuglog since a few days ago

https://debuglogs.org/06f0597d4577de7ef981b365c550235e7189746362c74e02f16ec0c43d2b1d66.zip

h9k commented 2 years ago

Same issue since a couple of days. iOS 15.1 on iPhone XR, app version 5.25.0.13. Tried disabling/enabling notifications and restarted the phone, nothing helped.

Btw the changelog says "several improvements to notification reliability" for version 5.25.0 released last week. It worked fine for me up to that point.

mitchellhenke commented 2 years ago

I am seeing this as well over the last couple of days. No push notifications or a notification bubble on the app.

iPhone XR on iOS 15.1 and version 5.25.0.13

https://debuglogs.org/3d2a77e49f409cdd9b9667432f96729fcd846c50159bff568afc8866e1511f73.zip

tonytx05 commented 2 years ago

I'm experiencing the same issue. iPhone 11, iOS 15.1, signal version 5.26.0.53.

Here the messages had been sent to me about 10 minutes before the log was generated: https://debuglogs.org/c9f7dda045f3acde4992351a11c7daae9672baf428230be3ee4eb0c32b61fec3.zip

For this one the messages were sent about 15 minutes prior to generating the log: https://debuglogs.org/1e56ea5e7805c5349dbebee57e0143e329ad1b97731243dec068a215d0e5f401.zip

tonytx05 commented 2 years ago

I think the notification issue is caused by Focus modes. However, I added specific contacts to the list of people I would allow notifications from and also added Signal to the list of apps to allow. It didn't seem to make a difference, as notifications never came through until I opened the app.

I noticed the same thing in another application, which made me think this might not be an isolated Signal issue. Turning off focus modes has fixed the problem, at least for now.

h9k commented 2 years ago

I'm not using focus modes, yet I still have the issue. I don't think any other app has issues on my device. Actually, it looks more and more apps are affected... so maybe this is just an iOS issue? My iPad is working fine, weirdly enough. Maybe I should reset the iPhone settings in an attempt to solve this...

EmDee commented 2 years ago

I've been seeing this issue since updating to iOS 15. Happens in WhatsApp for me as well, so definitely seems like an iOS issue or some change in regard to background fetch and/or push notification.

nickcharles commented 2 years ago

For those following, I performed a full factory reset on my phone the other day for unrelated reasons, and I have noticed that I've been getting Signal notifications since then. Might be worth trying if a reset isn't super costly for you.

tonytx05 commented 2 years ago

Latest time this happened to me. Messages arrived 9–10 minutes before I opened the app and generated these logs, but I did not receive any notification. When I opened the app, I got the banner notifications for the messages that had been sent.

https://debuglogs.org/12f319a835644bacf3b5cf3a5566afdf7989a624aa81f9f74d7c5afc3c631ae6.zip

tonytx05 commented 2 years ago

Another instance of no notifications until the app is opened.

https://debuglogs.org/070e87e77a6694dad0c82729f377773849e27ed9721499c9fc6021eaf69c74bb.zip

h9k commented 2 years ago

For those following, I performed a full factory reset on my phone the other day for unrelated reasons, and I have noticed that I've been getting Signal notifications since then. Might be worth trying if a reset isn't super costly for you.

I tried resetting all iOS settings, unfortunately that did not help. A factory reset would be a bold move. I think I will wait for the next iOS update and live with the frustration until then.

Bikeno commented 2 years ago

https://debuglogs.org/74571dade16ee59c0a84102915cf2877fcd1ba22cc4fd0f6184171b2155fabb2.zip

Same as majority above - no push notifications unless Signal was used within 5-15min. “Re-register push notifications” button does not help.

h9k commented 2 years ago

In the end, tinkering with settings did not help, nor did it help to perform a settings reset on iOS. What helped was to reinstall Signal. This applied to Telegram and Whatsapp also, which also stopped notifying me. Since meanwhile most of my apps are affected, I think that a factory reset will be the only way to go as all apps will be reinstalled when restoring the backup. As this does not appear to be a Signal bug, I think this issue should be closed.

wilhk commented 2 years ago

Same here. Still not working even I tried reinstalling Signal, Re-register for notification, add Signal to 'always on' list on my iphone, this is so annoying.

iPhone 12 Pro Max iOS: 15.1.1 Signal : 5.26.5.0

lastralab commented 2 years ago

Is someone aleeady working on this?

savageawakening commented 2 years ago

I had this same issue pop up, also presumably since the IOS15 update but just noticed it today when a friend texted me from another app to see if I was still alive after failing to respond for several days. I really wanted to avoid having to delete the app as I did not want to lose my history. Just restarting the phone or force quitting Signal did not work but I was able to fix it. I have no idea if this entire procedure was needed but it's what I did and notifications started rolling in again:

From that point, notifications were working again for me.

My logic for trying these steps was maybe the config is only read at application start, so I figured I would make sure to start the app with each setting off then each setting on again to make sure any cached or temp files were overwritten with the settings I was selecting.

Evachanel commented 2 years ago

if the Signal app is closed, no notifications. When i open the app, notifications are shown. All settings correct for push notifications on both my phone and the app. I can’t reinstall the app or I will lose my conversations as we have no option to save them on IOS (this problem should also be fixed) Please help. iPhone XR Signal 5.26.7.2 / iOS 15.0.2

lisamowagner commented 2 years ago

Same issue.

I have tried the suggested solutions from this thread and even reset all my settings on my phone, it persists.

iPhone XS iOS 15.2 Signal 5.26.8.0 Debug Log: https://debuglogs.org/b290d58d7a76ce63adf7f35d1e63af64ab64e91f45b939d7a21e1c7ec488f881.zip

EDIT: After being able to transfer my messages to another device (to keep them), I deleted and reinstalled the app and now I do receive notifications again.

jymclarke commented 2 years ago

Same issue ever since I upgraded to ios 15:

IOS 15.2 Signal 5.25.8.0 iPhone 6s

flostyen commented 2 years ago

I have multiple friends who suffer from the same issue. But its not only Signal, they also have this issue in Theema and Telegram.

A friend just told me, that un- and re-installing Signal solved the problem for him.

maelikk commented 2 years ago

Problem solved without knowing why.

I wonder if this has to do with the removal of a third-party application that was handling notifications for my connected bracelet? (huawei health)

IOS 15.2 5.26.8.0 iPhone 13 Pro Max

christian-putzke commented 2 years ago

I'm having this issue since over 3 months now: Getting no push notifications at all or getting them heavily delayed. I see them instantly when I open the app on my iPhone though. Maybe it is worth to say that I'm using the Desktop App in addition to the iPhone App.

Currently I'm on iOS 15.2 using Signal 5.26.9.2 on my iPhone 8.

I'm wondering if anyone from the Signal Team is already actively looking into this issue or not?

It is really frustrating to use Signal like that and it would be very much appreciated if that can be fixed.