search

simplajs / simpla

Open, modular, and serverless content management for a modern web
https://www.simplajs.org
MIT License
527 stars 36 forks source link

SimplaJs with Polymer2 won't work out of the box #87

Closed contis2908 closed 6 years ago

contis2908 commented 6 years ago

I'm submitting a

I am submitting a feature request regarding the implementation of Polymer version 2

Description

I tried to set up SimplaJS with the basic Polymer 2 starter kit as well as the Polymer 2 entry application that can be both installed with the Polymer cli. Unfortunately this is not working out of the box due to several dependency issues.

The following simpla imports require Polymer#^1.6.0. simpla-admin#1.3.1, simpla-img#1.3.2, simpla-notify#1.0.1, simpla-styles#1.0.4, simpla-text#1.2.2, simple-button#0.2.4, simple-dropdown#0.2.2

This version of Polymer is not supporting the class based syntax which ships with Polymer 2

Futher details

steps to reproduce problem: Install Polymer cli and one of the available Polymer packages (starter-kit or app)

Browsers Affected

madeleineostoja commented 6 years ago

Yes, Simpla's elements are still on Polymer 1, this is a high priority issue for us, follow progress (and feel free to make PRs!) at #79

bedeoverend commented 6 years ago

This raises a point that might be worth considering after #79 - with ditching HTML and going completely JS we might have to look into how we can backwards support Polymer 2 ie HTML imports + ES6 classes.

It might be that we just show people how to wrap them up, I’d rather not export HTML imports unless it’s a huge sticking point for people.

madeleineostoja commented 6 years ago

Well it's not like they're incompatible, it's just DX, and with Polymer 3 w/ the same workflow immanent, I wouldn't worry about it