simplex-chat / simplex-chat

SimpleX - the first messaging network operating without user identifiers of any kind - 100% private by design! iOS, Android and desktop apps 📱!
https://simplex.chat
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
6.19k stars 289 forks source link

Bug: Videos or images in any group is gone after 2 days + solution #3836

Open User1l0 opened 7 months ago

User1l0 commented 7 months ago

Any media that is posted in a group, can't load after couple of days. Please fix this.

Possible solution to this, is making the media files sync across the members who already have cached the video or image in their client making it possible for other members to be able to download the media after the file expires in the server.

Losing media in just 2 days is horrible, you can't see what people posted if you don't use simplex more than 2 days. This is really wrong, hope it gets fixed soon.

dillfrescott commented 7 months ago

Under the database settings, is the option to remove messages set to 2 days or so?

Screenshot 2024-03-02 003136

User1l0 commented 7 months ago

Under the database settings, is the option to remove messages set to 2 days or so?

Screenshot 2024-03-02 003136

It's by default set to never, but in every group chat media expires after couple of days, and it's impossibly to load any video or picture

pedrodelbosque commented 6 months ago

All media files are deleted 48 hours after upload from servers, as seen in PRIVACY.md The files are stored on file relay servers for the time configured in the relay servers you use (48 hours for preset file servers).

As for now, if you want to have media stored on servers for more than 2 days, run your own server or upload it somewhere else, encrypt and link it (messages are stored 21 days)

User1l0 commented 6 months ago

All media files are deleted 48 hours after upload from servers, as seen in PRIVACY.md The files are stored on file relay servers for the time configured in the relay servers you use (48 hours for preset file servers).

As for now, if you want to have media stored on servers for more than 2 days, run your own server or upload it somewhere else, encrypt and link it (messages are stored 21 days)

This makes very difficult to use simplex, just to extend media expiration having even a server running with the with app. This betterbe fixed with alternative method. Like letting other y Users in the group being able the receive from your ready media, so there's no more difficulties being able to catch media without setting a separate server just for that. This is too much for a simple privacy messenger. It's a very big problem, and it needs to be fixed

User1l0 commented 6 months ago

All media files are deleted 48 hours after upload from servers, as seen in PRIVACY.md The files are stored on file relay servers for the time configured in the relay servers you use (48 hours for preset file servers). As for now, if you want to have media stored on servers for more than 2 days, run your own server or upload it somewhere else, encrypt and link it (messages are stored 21 days)

This makes very difficult to use simplex, just to extend media expiration having even a server running with the with app. This betterbe fixed with alternative method. Like letting other y Users in the group being able the receive from your ready media, so there's no more difficulties being able to catch media without setting a separate server just for that. This is too much for a simple privacy messenger. It's a very big problem, and it needs to be fixed

Also it isnt fair and doesn't look decentralized while even in your own group has this issues, and not even a setting to keep media in the server forever or less.

User1l0 commented 6 months ago

All media files are deleted 48 hours after upload from servers, as seen in PRIVACY.md The files are stored on file relay servers for the time configured in the relay servers you use (48 hours for preset file servers). As for now, if you want to have media stored on servers for more than 2 days, run your own server or upload it somewhere else, encrypt and link it (messages are stored 21 days)

This makes very difficult to use simplex, just to extend media expiration having even a server running with the with app. This betterbe fixed with alternative method. Like letting other y Users in the group being able the receive from your ready media, so there's no more difficulties being able to catch media without setting a separate server just for that. This is too much for a simple privacy messenger. It's a very big problem, and it needs to be fixed

Also it isnt fair and doesn't look decentralized while even in your own group has this issues, and not even a setting to keep media in the server forever or less.

This can be solved just by torrent style file sharing, when you have the file you can share it and others in the group can view the media whenever they need. This is just best solution, please make people normally use simplex, not the way that any media you see in any simplex group becomes unavailable after 2 days