simsab-ufcg / Promethee2

Implementation of Promethee with optimization
MIT License
12 stars 7 forks source link

Are the samples correct? #60

Open danielmitre opened 1 year ago

danielmitre commented 1 year ago

I was unable to run the samples myself, but as I'm working on a Rust implementation and my output didn't match the values on the outputs folder. I also implemented the algorithm in different ways in Google Sheets and they matched my implementation.

What I expected (yours) ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/25506375/221972213-7dc5f9c4-1c86-4764-992c-581218c3443a.png)
What I got (my implementation) ![image](https://user-images.githubusercontent.com/25506375/221973219-fed48b5a-6907-4cfa-b314-28ae7b9439c9.png)

Guess 1 I may have misunderstood the criterias, here's what I got from reading the .input parser:

Guess 2 I may have misunderstood the input/output files.

Guess 3 My implementations may be wrong as I didn't find any Promethee calculator to test against, although it matched the algorithm presented in this video (https://youtu.be/xe2XgGrI0Sg - after correcting a mistake they did).