Shadowpriest DPS calculation BUG using Shadowcrash vs Legacy of The Void talents

Puregold68 commented 6 years ago

Please include a brief overview of the issue in the title above, as well as completing the following:

Hello all and thanks for your attention.

I simcrafted my shadowpriest with 949 ilvl, with default Patchwerk single target fight.

Using the talent Legacy of the Void talent I get 1354841 dps. With Shadowcrash I get 1414189 dps (around 4.4% extra dps - ???!!!) . It's very strange since Shadocrash is more like a AOE spell that is decent for Mythic+ all around but in raids is a Single Target DPS nerf (or at least should be).

Im sure that one of this simulations (if not both) is using a wrong model or wrong formulas and need to be fixed.

My Shadowpriest name is Puregold from Silvermoon-EU

Simulationcraft Version

735.01

Simulation With Legacy of the Void

DPS Ranking: 1354841 100.0% Raid 1354841 100.0% Puregold

HPS Ranking: 0 100.0% Raid

Player: Puregold human priest shadow 110 DPS: 1354841.0 DPS-Error=2707.5/0.200% DPS-Range=226935/16.7% DPS-Convergence=70.2% HPS: 0.0 HPS-Error=0.0/0.0%

Origin: https://eu.api.battle.net/wow/character/silvermoon/Puregold/advanced Talents: https://worldofwarcraft.com/en-us/game/talent-calculator#priest/shadow/talents=2111231 Artifact: Core Stats: strength=6254|5929(5929) agility=7829|7504(7504) stamina=84412|84412(57443) intellect=60539|58833(56398) spirit=0|0(0) health=5064720|5064720 mana=1100000|1100000 Generic Stats: mastery=62.13%|62.13%(6738) versatility=3.32%|3.32%(1579) leech=0.00%|0.00%(0) runspeed=7.14%|7.14%(0) Spell Stats: power=60539|58833(0) hit=15.00%|15.00%(0) crit=31.80%|31.80%(10722) haste=42.05%|41.03%(15387) speed=42.05%|41.03% manareg=8800|8800(0) Attack Stats: power=0|0(0) hit=7.50%|7.50%(0) crit=31.80%|31.80%(10722) expertise=7.50%|7.50%(0) haste=42.05%|41.03%(15387) speed=42.05%|41.03% Defense Stats: armor=2247|2247(2247) miss=3.00%|3.00% dodge=3.00%|3.00%(0) parry=0.00%|0.00%(0) block=0.00%|0.00%(0) crit=0.00%|0.00% versatility=1.66%|1.66%(1579) Priorities (actions.precombat): flask/food/augmentation/snapshot_stats variable,name=haste_eval,op=set,value=(raw_haste_pct-0.3)(10+10equipped.mangazas_madness+5talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled) variable,name=haste_eval,op=max,value=0 variable,name=erupt_eval,op=set,value=26+1talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled-4talent.Sanlayn.enabled-3talent.Shadowy_insight.enabled+variable.haste_eval1.5 variable,name=cd_time,op=set,value=(12+(2-2talent.mindbender.enabledset_bonus.tier20_4pc)set_bonus.tier19_2pc+(1-3talent.mindbender.enabledset_bonus.tier20_4pc)equipped.mangazas_madness+(6+5talent.mindbender.enabled)set_bonus.tier20_4pc+2artifact.lash_of_insanity.rank) variable,name=dot_swp_dpgcd,op=set,value=36.51.2(1+0.06artifact.to_the_pain.rank)(1+0.2+stat.mastery_rating%16000)0.75 variable,name=dot_vt_dpgcd,op=set,value=681.2(1+0.2talent.sanlayn.enabled)(1+0.05artifact.touch_of_darkness.rank)(1+0.2+stat.mastery_rating%16000)0.5 variable,name=sear_dpgcd,op=set,value=1201.2(1+0.05artifact.void_corruption.rank) variable,name=s2msetup_time,op=set,value=(0.8(83+(20+20talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled)set_bonus.tier20_4pc-(5talent.sanlayn.enabled)+((33-13set_bonus.tier20_4pc)talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled)+set_bonus.tier19_2pc4+8equipped.mangazas_madness+(raw_haste_pct10(1+0.7set_bonus.tier20_4pc))(2+(0.8set_bonus.tier19_2pc)+(1talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled)+(2artifact.mass_hysteria.rank)-(1talent.sanlayn.enabled)))),if=talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled potion/shadowform,if=!buff.shadowform.up/mind_blast Priorities: potion,if=buff.bloodlust.react|target.time_to_die<=80|(target.health.pct<35&cooldown.power_infusion.remains<30) call_action_list,name=check,if=talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&!buff.surrender_to_madness.up run_action_list,name=s2m,if=buff.voidform.up&buff.surrender_to_madness.up run_action_list,name=vf,if=buff.voidform.up/run_action_list,name=main Priorities (actions.main): surrender_to_madness,if=talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die<=variable.s2mcheck shadow_word_death,if=equipped.zeks_exterminatus&equipped.mangazas_madness&buff.zeks_exterminatus.react shadow_word_pain,if=talent.misery.enabled&dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<gcd.max,moving=1,cycle_targets=1 vampiric_touch,if=talent.misery.enabled&(dot.vampiric_touch.remains<3gcd.max|dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<3gcd.max),cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_pain,if=!talent.misery.enabled&dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<(3+(4%3))gcd vampiric_touch,if=!talent.misery.enabled&dot.vampiric_touch.remains<(4+(4%3))gcd void_eruption,if=(talent.mindbender.enabled&cooldown.mindbender.remains<(variable.erupt_eval+gcd.max4%3))|!talent.mindbender.enabled|set_bonus.tier20_4pc shadow_crash,if=talent.shadow_crash.enabled shadow_word_death,if=(active_enemies<=4|(talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled&active_enemies<=2))&cooldown.shadow_word_death.charges=2&insanity<=(85-15talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled)|(equipped.zeks_exterminatus&buff.zeks_exterminatus.react) mind_blast,if=active_enemies<=4&talent.legacy_of_the_void.enabled&(insanity<=81|(insanity<=75.2&talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled)) mind_blast,if=active_enemies<=4&!talent.legacy_of_the_void.enabled|(insanity<=96|(insanity<=95.2&talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled)) shadow_word_pain,if=!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&target.time_to_die>10&(active_enemies<5&(talent.auspicious_spirits.enabled|talent.shadowy_insight.enabled)),cycle_targets=1 vampiric_touch,if=active_enemies>1&!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&(variable.dot_vt_dpgcdtarget.time_to_die%(gcd.max(156+variable.sear_dpgcd(active_enemies-1))))>1,cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_pain,if=active_enemies>1&!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&(variable.dot_swp_dpgcdtarget.time_to_die%(gcd.max(118+variable.sear_dpgcd(active_enemies-1))))>1,cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_void,if=talent.shadow_word_void.enabled&(insanity<=75-10talent.legacy_of_the_void.enabled) mind_flay,interrupt=1,chain=1/shadow_word_pain Priorities (actions.vf): surrender_to_madness,if=talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&insanity>=25&(cooldown.void_bolt.up|cooldown.void_torrent.up|cooldown.shadow_word_death.up|buff.shadowy_insight.up)&target.time_to_die<=variable.s2mcheck-(buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value) silence,if=equipped.sephuzs_secret&(target.is_add|target.debuff.casting.react)&cooldown.buff_sephuzs_secret.up&!buff.sephuzs_secret.up&buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value>10,cycle_targets=1 void_bolt shadow_word_death,if=equipped.zeks_exterminatus&equipped.mangazas_madness&buff.zeks_exterminatus.react mind_bomb,if=equipped.sephuzs_secret&target.is_add&cooldown.buff_sephuzs_secret.remains<1&!buff.sephuzs_secret.up&buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value>10,cycle_targets=1 shadow_crash,if=talent.shadow_crash.enabled void_torrent,if=dot.shadow_word_pain.remains>5.5&dot.vampiric_touch.remains>5.5&(!talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled|(talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die>variable.s2mcheck-(buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value)+60)) mindbender,if=buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value>=(variable.cd_time+(variable.haste_eval!set_bonus.tier20_4pc)-(3set_bonus.tier20_4pc(raid_event.movement.in<15)((active_enemies-(raid_event.adds.count(raid_event.adds.remains>0)))=1))+(5-3set_bonus.tier20_4pc)buff.bloodlust.up+2talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabledset_bonus.tier20_4pc)&(!talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled|(talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die>variable.s2mcheck-buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value)) power_infusion,if=buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value>=(variable.cd_time+5buff.bloodlust.up(1+1set_bonus.tier20_4pc))&(!talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled|(talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die>variable.s2mcheck-(buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value)+61)) berserking,if=buff.voidform.stack>=10&buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value<=20&(!talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled|(talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die>variable.s2mcheck-(buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value)+60)) shadow_word_death,if=(active_enemies<=4|(talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled&active_enemies<=2))&current_insanity_draingcd.max>insanity&(insanity-(current_insanity_draingcd.max)+(15+15talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled))<100 wait,sec=action.void_bolt.usable_in,if=action.void_bolt.usable_in<gcd.max0.28 mind_blast,if=active_enemies<=4 wait,sec=action.mind_blast.usable_in,if=action.mind_blast.usable_in<gcd.max0.28&active_enemies<=4 shadow_word_death,if=(active_enemies<=4|(talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled&active_enemies<=2))&cooldown.shadow_word_death.charges=2|(equipped.zeks_exterminatus&buff.zeks_exterminatus.react) shadowfiend,if=!talent.mindbender.enabled&buff.voidform.stack>15 shadow_word_void,if=talent.shadow_word_void.enabled&(insanity-(current_insanity_draingcd.max)+25)<100 shadow_word_pain,if=talent.misery.enabled&dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<gcd,moving=1,cycle_targets=1 vampiric_touch,if=talent.misery.enabled&(dot.vampiric_touch.remains<3gcd.max|dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<3gcd.max)&target.time_to_die>5gcd.max,cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_pain,if=!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&(active_enemies<5|talent.auspicious_spirits.enabled|talent.shadowy_insight.enabled|artifact.sphere_of_insanity.rank) vampiric_touch,if=!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&(active_enemies<4|talent.sanlayn.enabled|(talent.auspicious_spirits.enabled&artifact.unleash_the_shadows.rank)) vampiric_touch,if=active_enemies>1&!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&((1+0.02buff.voidform.stack)variable.dot_vt_dpgcdtarget.time_to_die%(gcd.max(156+variable.sear_dpgcd(active_enemies-1))))>1,cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_pain,if=active_enemies>1&!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&((1+0.02buff.voidform.stack)variable.dot_swp_dpgcdtarget.time_to_die%(gcd.max(118+variable.sear_dpgcd(active_enemies-1))))>1,cycle_targets=1 mind_flay,chain=1,interrupt_immediate=1,interrupt_if=ticks>=2&(action.void_bolt.usable|(current_insanity_draingcd.max>insanity&(insanity-(current_insanity_drain*gcd.max)+30)<100&cooldown.shadow_word_death.charges>=1)) shadow_word_pain Actions: mark_of_the_hidden_satyr Count= 29.2| 10.18sec DPE= 207556| 1% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 20255 Miss=0.00% Hit=157590|137613|203515 Crit=315107|275226|407031|31.7% mental_fortitude Count=200.3| 1.48sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 Miss=0.00% mind_blast Count= 52.3| 5.63sec DPE= 893316|12% DPET= 1128212 DPR=0.0 pDPS=156622 Miss=0.00% Hit=533786|419993|705824 Crit=1348580|1049982|1764561|42.1% mind_flay Count=139.8| 2.13sec DPE= 567744|17% DPET= 545525 DPR=0.0 pDPS=225939 TickCount=384 MissTick=0.0% Tick=108468|88065|147998 CritTick=275954|220163|369995|40.6% UpTime=46.6% mind_flay_void_tendril Count=113.4| 2.39sec DPE= 102686| 3% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 39033 Miss=0.00% Hit=77865|72247|89038 Crit=155735|144494|178076|31.9% mind_sear_tick Count=383.4| 0.77sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 mindbender Count= 4.9| 61.06sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 personnel_decimator Count= 46.7| 6.41sec DPE= 511864| 6% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 80010 Miss=0.00% Hit=389177|367230|440676 Crit=778171|734461|881353|31.5% potion Count= 2.0| 0.00sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 shadow_word_death Count= 5.2| 10.03sec DPE= 734226| 1% DPET= 927713 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 12730 Miss=0.00% Hit=555418|452326|633468 Crit=1111469|904652|1266936|32.1% shadow_word_pain Count= 2.3| 67.00sec DPE=22701914|11% DPET=23999877 DPR=0.0 pDPS=151472 Miss=0.00% Hit=72156|63968|94601 Crit=144416|127936|189202|31.3% TickCount=304 MissTick=0.0% Tick=112640|46634|227902 CritTick=225146|62737|455805|31.7% UpTime=99.9% shadowy_apparitions Count=134.6| 2.21sec DPE= 75353| 3% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 33921 Miss=0.00% Hit=58095|45895|77129 Crit=116170|91790|154258|31.8% sphere_of_insanity Count=384.8| 0.75sec DPE= 20869| 2% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 26899 Miss=0.00% Hit=20870|4991|88228 vampiric_touch Count= 1.8|147.96sec DPE=30533424|14% DPET=35716906 DPR=0.0 pDPS=188354 TickCount=201 MissTick=0.0% Tick=212337|76448|429087 CritTick=424798|160736|858174|31.7% UpTime=99.2% void_bolt Count= 91.1| 3.18sec DPE= 790492|18% DPET= 994429 DPR=0.0 pDPS=241136 Miss=0.00% Hit=547555|478407|707513 Crit=1098081|956814|1415025|44.3% void_eruption Count= 5.4| 59.35sec DPE= 1848606| 2% DPET= 1954820 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 33544 Miss=0.00% Hit=1406391|1231653|1821484 Crit=2810190|2463305|3642968|31.7% void_torrent Count= 5.3| 61.41sec DPE= 3497604| 5% DPET= 828469 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 61526 TickCount=50 MissTick=0.0% Tick=277769|485|379478 CritTick=556057|1116|758955|31.7% UpTime=7.0% mindbender (DPS=234697.9) melee Count=143.2| 1.81sec DPE= 174391| 6% DPET= 238445 DPR=0.0 pDPS=234698 Miss=0.00% Hit=132324|108370|153591 Crit=264508|216741|307181|31.8% shadowcrawl Count= 19.1| 14.04sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 Constant Buffs: azshari_salad/defiled_augmentation/flask_of_the_whispered_pact Dynamic Buffs: bloodlust : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=13.57% benefit=14% concordance_of_the_legionfall : start= 8.3 refresh= 3.2 interval= 35.4 trigger= 24.8 uptime=32.28% benefit=32% insanity_drain_stacks : start= 5.4 refresh=217.8 interval= 59.3 trigger= 59.3 uptime=80.37% benefit=100% lingering_insanity : start= 4.5 refresh= 0.0 interval= 59.5 trigger= 59.5 uptime=34.98% benefit=35% mental_fortitude : start= 1.0 refresh=199.3 interval= 3.5 trigger= 1.5 uptime=98.81% benefit=99% mind_quickening : start= 5.3 refresh= 0.0 interval= 61.5 trigger= 61.5 uptime=25.67% benefit=26% overwhelming_darkness : start= 5.4 refresh= 0.0 interval= 59.3 trigger= 59.3 uptime=80.37% benefit=80% potion_of_prolonged_power : start= 2.0 refresh= 0.0 interval=209.5 trigger= 0.0 uptime=40.03% benefit=40% shadowform : start= 5.5 refresh= 0.0 interval= 58.8 trigger= 59.5 uptime=19.63% benefit=20% sphere_of_insanity : start= 5.4 refresh= 0.0 interval= 59.3 trigger= 59.3 uptime=80.37% benefit=76% twist_of_fate : start= 1.0 refresh=313.1 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.3 uptime=30.38% benefit=30% void_torrent : start= 5.3 refresh= 0.0 interval= 61.5 trigger= 61.5 uptime= 6.97% benefit= 7% voidform : start= 5.4 refresh= 0.0 interval= 59.3 trigger= 59.3 uptime=80.37% benefit=79% mindbender-shadowcrawl : start=19.1 refresh= 0.0 interval= 14.0 trigger= 14.0 uptime=86.67% benefit=88% Procs: 134.7 | 2.21sec : Shadowy Apparition Insanity lost to overflow 5.4 | 59.33sec : Void Eruption casted when a target with DoTs was up 11.6 | 24.72sec : Void Tendril spawned from Call to the Void Gains: 313.4 : Insanity Gained from Auspicious Spirits (insanity) (overflow=21.1%) 821.0 : Insanity Gained from Mind Blast (insanity) (overflow=14.4%) 1072.8 : Insanity Gained from Mind Flay (insanity) (overflow=22.3%) 995.6 : Insanity Gained from Mindbender (insanity) (overflow=13.1%) 58.2 : Insanity Gained from Shadow Word: Death (insanity) (overflow=25.7%) 4.4 : Insanity Gained from Shadow Word: Pain Casts (insanity) (overflow=53.3%) 6.3 : Insanity Gained from Vampiric Touch Casts (insanity) (overflow=43.3%) 971.5 : Insanity Gained from Void Bolt (insanity) (overflow=33.3%) 220440.0 : Health from Vampiric Touch Ticks (health) (overflow=99.2%) 260.2 : Insanity Gained from Call to the Void (insanity) (overflow=23.5%) 0.0 : mp5_regen (mana) (overflow=100.0%) Waiting: 0.00%

Targets

Actions: Constant Buffs: bleeding/mortal_wounds Dynamic Buffs: Health Decade (0 - 10) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 8.43% benefit= 8% Health Decade (10 - 20) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 8.49% benefit= 8% Health Decade (20 - 30) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 9.02% benefit= 9% Health Decade (30 - 40) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 9.94% benefit=10% Health Decade (40 - 50) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=10.90% benefit=11% Health Decade (50 - 60) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=11.36% benefit=11% Health Decade (60 - 70) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=11.52% benefit=12% Health Decade (70 - 80) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=10.60% benefit=11% Health Decade (80 - 90) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 8.41% benefit= 8% Health Decade (90 - 100) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=11.33% benefit=11% Waiting: 0.00% Baseline Performance: RNG Engine = sse2-sfmt Iterations = 2484 (854, 545, 555, 530) TotalEvents = 13316117 MaxEventQueue = 48 TargetHealth = 485826503 SimSeconds = 744744 CpuSeconds = 23.562 WallSeconds = 7.987 InitSeconds = 0.478436 MergeSeconds = 0.001828 AnalyzeSeconds= 0.004332 SpeedUp = 31607 EndTime = 2018-05-03 11:12:15+0100 (1525342335)

Waiting: 0.0% : Puregold

Simulation With Shadowcrash

DPS Ranking: 1414189 100.0% Raid 1414189 100.0% Puregold

HPS Ranking: 0 100.0% Raid

Player: Puregold human priest shadow 110 DPS: 1414188.9 DPS-Error=2817.4/0.199% DPS-Range=163752/11.6% DPS-Convergence=69.9% HPS: 0.0 HPS-Error=0.0/0.0%

Origin: https://eu.api.battle.net/wow/character/silvermoon/Puregold/advanced Talents: https://worldofwarcraft.com/en-us/game/talent-calculator#priest/shadow/talents=2111232 Artifact: Core Stats: strength=6254|5929(5929) agility=7829|7504(7504) stamina=84412|84412(57443) intellect=60539|58833(56398) spirit=0|0(0) health=5064720|5064720 mana=1100000|1100000 Generic Stats: mastery=62.13%|62.13%(6738) versatility=3.32%|3.32%(1579) leech=0.00%|0.00%(0) runspeed=7.14%|7.14%(0) Spell Stats: power=60539|58833(0) hit=15.00%|15.00%(0) crit=31.80%|31.80%(10722) haste=42.05%|41.03%(15387) speed=42.05%|41.03% manareg=8800|8800(0) Attack Stats: power=0|0(0) hit=7.50%|7.50%(0) crit=31.80%|31.80%(10722) expertise=7.50%|7.50%(0) haste=42.05%|41.03%(15387) speed=42.05%|41.03% Defense Stats: armor=2247|2247(2247) miss=3.00%|3.00% dodge=3.00%|3.00%(0) parry=0.00%|0.00%(0) block=0.00%|0.00%(0) crit=0.00%|0.00% versatility=1.66%|1.66%(1579) Priorities (actions.precombat): flask/food/augmentation/snapshot_stats variable,name=haste_eval,op=set,value=(raw_haste_pct-0.3)(10+10equipped.mangazas_madness+5talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled) variable,name=haste_eval,op=max,value=0 variable,name=erupt_eval,op=set,value=26+1talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled-4talent.Sanlayn.enabled-3talent.Shadowy_insight.enabled+variable.haste_eval1.5 variable,name=cd_time,op=set,value=(12+(2-2talent.mindbender.enabledset_bonus.tier20_4pc)set_bonus.tier19_2pc+(1-3talent.mindbender.enabledset_bonus.tier20_4pc)equipped.mangazas_madness+(6+5talent.mindbender.enabled)set_bonus.tier20_4pc+2artifact.lash_of_insanity.rank) variable,name=dot_swp_dpgcd,op=set,value=36.51.2(1+0.06artifact.to_the_pain.rank)(1+0.2+stat.mastery_rating%16000)0.75 variable,name=dot_vt_dpgcd,op=set,value=681.2(1+0.2talent.sanlayn.enabled)(1+0.05artifact.touch_of_darkness.rank)(1+0.2+stat.mastery_rating%16000)0.5 variable,name=sear_dpgcd,op=set,value=1201.2(1+0.05artifact.void_corruption.rank) variable,name=s2msetup_time,op=set,value=(0.8(83+(20+20talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled)set_bonus.tier20_4pc-(5talent.sanlayn.enabled)+((33-13set_bonus.tier20_4pc)talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled)+set_bonus.tier19_2pc4+8equipped.mangazas_madness+(raw_haste_pct10(1+0.7set_bonus.tier20_4pc))(2+(0.8set_bonus.tier19_2pc)+(1talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled)+(2artifact.mass_hysteria.rank)-(1talent.sanlayn.enabled)))),if=talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled potion/shadowform,if=!buff.shadowform.up/mind_blast Priorities: potion,if=buff.bloodlust.react|target.time_to_die<=80|(target.health.pct<35&cooldown.power_infusion.remains<30) call_action_list,name=check,if=talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&!buff.surrender_to_madness.up run_action_list,name=s2m,if=buff.voidform.up&buff.surrender_to_madness.up run_action_list,name=vf,if=buff.voidform.up/run_action_list,name=main Priorities (actions.main): surrender_to_madness,if=talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die<=variable.s2mcheck shadow_word_death,if=equipped.zeks_exterminatus&equipped.mangazas_madness&buff.zeks_exterminatus.react shadow_word_pain,if=talent.misery.enabled&dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<gcd.max,moving=1,cycle_targets=1 vampiric_touch,if=talent.misery.enabled&(dot.vampiric_touch.remains<3gcd.max|dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<3gcd.max),cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_pain,if=!talent.misery.enabled&dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<(3+(4%3))gcd vampiric_touch,if=!talent.misery.enabled&dot.vampiric_touch.remains<(4+(4%3))gcd void_eruption,if=(talent.mindbender.enabled&cooldown.mindbender.remains<(variable.erupt_eval+gcd.max4%3))|!talent.mindbender.enabled|set_bonus.tier20_4pc shadow_crash,if=talent.shadow_crash.enabled shadow_word_death,if=(active_enemies<=4|(talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled&active_enemies<=2))&cooldown.shadow_word_death.charges=2&insanity<=(85-15talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled)|(equipped.zeks_exterminatus&buff.zeks_exterminatus.react) mind_blast,if=active_enemies<=4&talent.legacy_of_the_void.enabled&(insanity<=81|(insanity<=75.2&talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled)) mind_blast,if=active_enemies<=4&!talent.legacy_of_the_void.enabled|(insanity<=96|(insanity<=95.2&talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabled)) shadow_word_pain,if=!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&target.time_to_die>10&(active_enemies<5&(talent.auspicious_spirits.enabled|talent.shadowy_insight.enabled)),cycle_targets=1 vampiric_touch,if=active_enemies>1&!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&(variable.dot_vt_dpgcdtarget.time_to_die%(gcd.max(156+variable.sear_dpgcd(active_enemies-1))))>1,cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_pain,if=active_enemies>1&!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&(variable.dot_swp_dpgcdtarget.time_to_die%(gcd.max(118+variable.sear_dpgcd(active_enemies-1))))>1,cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_void,if=talent.shadow_word_void.enabled&(insanity<=75-10talent.legacy_of_the_void.enabled) mind_flay,interrupt=1,chain=1/shadow_word_pain Priorities (actions.vf): surrender_to_madness,if=talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&insanity>=25&(cooldown.void_bolt.up|cooldown.void_torrent.up|cooldown.shadow_word_death.up|buff.shadowy_insight.up)&target.time_to_die<=variable.s2mcheck-(buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value) silence,if=equipped.sephuzs_secret&(target.is_add|target.debuff.casting.react)&cooldown.buff_sephuzs_secret.up&!buff.sephuzs_secret.up&buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value>10,cycle_targets=1 void_bolt shadow_word_death,if=equipped.zeks_exterminatus&equipped.mangazas_madness&buff.zeks_exterminatus.react mind_bomb,if=equipped.sephuzs_secret&target.is_add&cooldown.buff_sephuzs_secret.remains<1&!buff.sephuzs_secret.up&buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value>10,cycle_targets=1 shadow_crash,if=talent.shadow_crash.enabled void_torrent,if=dot.shadow_word_pain.remains>5.5&dot.vampiric_touch.remains>5.5&(!talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled|(talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die>variable.s2mcheck-(buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value)+60)) mindbender,if=buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value>=(variable.cd_time+(variable.haste_eval!set_bonus.tier20_4pc)-(3set_bonus.tier20_4pc(raid_event.movement.in<15)((active_enemies-(raid_event.adds.count(raid_event.adds.remains>0)))=1))+(5-3set_bonus.tier20_4pc)buff.bloodlust.up+2talent.fortress_of_the_mind.enabledset_bonus.tier20_4pc)&(!talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled|(talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die>variable.s2mcheck-buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value)) power_infusion,if=buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value>=(variable.cd_time+5buff.bloodlust.up(1+1set_bonus.tier20_4pc))&(!talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled|(talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die>variable.s2mcheck-(buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value)+61)) berserking,if=buff.voidform.stack>=10&buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value<=20&(!talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled|(talent.surrender_to_madness.enabled&target.time_to_die>variable.s2mcheck-(buff.insanity_drain_stacks.value)+60)) shadow_word_death,if=(active_enemies<=4|(talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled&active_enemies<=2))&current_insanity_draingcd.max>insanity&(insanity-(current_insanity_draingcd.max)+(15+15talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled))<100 wait,sec=action.void_bolt.usable_in,if=action.void_bolt.usable_in<gcd.max0.28 mind_blast,if=active_enemies<=4 wait,sec=action.mind_blast.usable_in,if=action.mind_blast.usable_in<gcd.max0.28&active_enemies<=4 shadow_word_death,if=(active_enemies<=4|(talent.reaper_of_souls.enabled&active_enemies<=2))&cooldown.shadow_word_death.charges=2|(equipped.zeks_exterminatus&buff.zeks_exterminatus.react) shadowfiend,if=!talent.mindbender.enabled&buff.voidform.stack>15 shadow_word_void,if=talent.shadow_word_void.enabled&(insanity-(current_insanity_draingcd.max)+25)<100 shadow_word_pain,if=talent.misery.enabled&dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<gcd,moving=1,cycle_targets=1 vampiric_touch,if=talent.misery.enabled&(dot.vampiric_touch.remains<3gcd.max|dot.shadow_word_pain.remains<3gcd.max)&target.time_to_die>5gcd.max,cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_pain,if=!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&(active_enemies<5|talent.auspicious_spirits.enabled|talent.shadowy_insight.enabled|artifact.sphere_of_insanity.rank) vampiric_touch,if=!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&(active_enemies<4|talent.sanlayn.enabled|(talent.auspicious_spirits.enabled&artifact.unleash_the_shadows.rank)) vampiric_touch,if=active_enemies>1&!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&((1+0.02buff.voidform.stack)variable.dot_vt_dpgcdtarget.time_to_die%(gcd.max(156+variable.sear_dpgcd(active_enemies-1))))>1,cycle_targets=1 shadow_word_pain,if=active_enemies>1&!talent.misery.enabled&!ticking&((1+0.02buff.voidform.stack)variable.dot_swp_dpgcdtarget.time_to_die%(gcd.max(118+variable.sear_dpgcd(active_enemies-1))))>1,cycle_targets=1 mind_flay,chain=1,interrupt_immediate=1,interrupt_if=ticks>=2&(action.void_bolt.usable|(current_insanity_draingcd.max>insanity&(insanity-(current_insanity_drain*gcd.max)+30)<100&cooldown.shadow_word_death.charges>=1)) shadow_word_pain Actions: mark_of_the_hidden_satyr Count= 29.8| 10.05sec DPE= 206763| 1% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 20612 Miss=0.00% Hit=157371|137613|203515 Crit=314703|275226|407031|31.4% mental_fortitude Count=206.5| 1.44sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 Miss=0.00% mind_blast Count= 58.5| 5.07sec DPE= 857325|12% DPET= 1098224 DPR=0.0 pDPS=167294 Miss=0.00% Hit=511843|419993|677591 Crit=1290128|1049982|1693978|42.5% mind_flay Count=129.0| 2.31sec DPE= 551609|14% DPET= 558980 DPR=0.0 pDPS=197486 TickCount=339 MissTick=0.0% Tick=106475|87704|142078 CritTick=268795|220163|355196|42.0% UpTime=40.1% mind_flay_void_tendril Count=115.8| 2.33sec DPE= 102702| 3% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 39760 Miss=0.00% Hit=77858|72247|89038 Crit=155751|144494|178076|31.9% mind_sear_tick Count=339.1| 0.87sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 mindbender Count= 4.9| 61.04sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 personnel_decimator Count= 48.0| 6.21sec DPE= 511204| 6% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 81814 Miss=0.00% Hit=389477|367230|440676 Crit=778470|734461|881353|31.3% potion Count= 2.0| 0.00sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 shadow_crash Count= 14.8| 20.78sec DPE= 1260014| 4% DPET= 1594580 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 62181 Miss=0.00% Hit=1008988|821101|1324714 Crit=2019165|1642201|2649428|32.0% shadow_word_death Count= 5.2| 10.13sec DPE= 701047| 1% DPET= 895286 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 12248 Miss=0.00% Hit=532604|452326|608129 Crit=1067714|904652|1216258|31.5% shadow_word_pain Count= 1.4| 44.89sec DPE=39702169|11% DPET=40041276 DPR=0.0 pDPS=153599 Miss=0.00% Hit=72364|63968|94601 Crit=143589|127936|189202|31.5% TickCount=313 MissTick=0.0% Tick=111421|47962|220850 CritTick=222956|104044|437573|31.7% UpTime=99.9% shadowy_apparitions Count=138.7| 2.13sec DPE= 73217| 2% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 33862 Miss=0.00% Hit=56389|45895|74044 Crit=112721|91790|148088|31.9% sphere_of_insanity Count=387.6| 0.74sec DPE= 20681| 2% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 26753 Miss=0.00% Hit=20683|4792|84699 vampiric_touch Count= 1.2|199.00sec DPE=49917563|14% DPET=60737823 DPR=0.0 pDPS=191673 TickCount=207 MissTick=0.0% Tick=210010|103006|415810 CritTick=420654|179913|823847|31.8% UpTime=99.2% void_bolt Count= 97.6| 2.95sec DPE= 760447|18% DPET= 969779 DPR=0.0 pDPS=247644 Miss=0.00% Hit=525438|459271|679212 Crit=1052409|918541|1358424|44.8% void_eruption Count= 5.4| 59.53sec DPE= 1862610| 2% DPET= 2148969 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 33621 Miss=0.00% Hit=1413020|1231653|1821484 Crit=2815861|2463305|3642968|32.4% void_torrent Count= 5.3| 60.96sec DPE= 3577829| 4% DPET= 847843 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 63077 TickCount=53 MissTick=0.0% Tick=268405|466|364299 CritTick=535776|1341|728597|31.8% UpTime=7.0% mindbender (DPS=233477.1) melee Count=142.3| 1.81sec DPE= 174011| 6% DPET= 236748 DPR=0.0 pDPS=233477 Miss=0.00% Hit=132177|108370|153591 Crit=264127|216741|307181|31.7% shadowcrawl Count= 19.0| 14.03sec DPE= 0| 0% DPET= 0 DPR=0.0 pDPS= 0 Constant Buffs: azshari_salad/defiled_augmentation/flask_of_the_whispered_pact Dynamic Buffs: bloodlust : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=13.53% benefit=14% concordance_of_the_legionfall : start= 8.3 refresh= 3.1 interval= 35.6 trigger= 25.0 uptime=32.16% benefit=32% insanity_drain_stacks : start= 5.4 refresh=230.3 interval= 59.6 trigger= 59.6 uptime=84.29% benefit=100% lingering_insanity : start= 4.5 refresh= 0.0 interval= 60.2 trigger= 60.2 uptime=36.72% benefit=37% mental_fortitude : start= 1.0 refresh=205.5 interval= 3.5 trigger= 1.4 uptime=98.82% benefit=99% mind_quickening : start= 5.3 refresh= 0.0 interval= 60.9 trigger= 60.9 uptime=25.73% benefit=26% overwhelming_darkness : start= 5.4 refresh= 0.0 interval= 59.6 trigger= 59.6 uptime=84.29% benefit=84% potion_of_prolonged_power : start= 2.0 refresh= 0.0 interval=209.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=39.91% benefit=40% shadowform : start= 5.5 refresh= 0.0 interval= 59.8 trigger= 60.2 uptime=15.71% benefit=16% sphere_of_insanity : start= 5.4 refresh= 0.0 interval= 59.6 trigger= 59.6 uptime=84.29% benefit=80% twist_of_fate : start= 1.0 refresh=319.7 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.3 uptime=30.48% benefit=30% void_torrent : start= 5.3 refresh= 0.0 interval= 60.9 trigger= 60.9 uptime= 6.99% benefit= 7% voidform : start= 5.4 refresh= 0.0 interval= 59.6 trigger= 59.6 uptime=84.29% benefit=82% mindbender-shadowcrawl : start=19.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 14.0 trigger= 14.0 uptime=86.66% benefit=88% Procs: 138.8 | 2.14sec : Shadowy Apparition Insanity lost to overflow 5.4 | 59.58sec : Void Eruption casted when a target with DoTs was up 11.8 | 24.10sec : Void Tendril spawned from Call to the Void Gains: 329.9 : Insanity Gained from Auspicious Spirits (insanity) (overflow=19.4%) 889.9 : Insanity Gained from Mind Blast (insanity) (overflow=16.9%) 1064.6 : Insanity Gained from Mind Flay (insanity) (overflow=12.8%) 1090.6 : Insanity Gained from Mindbender (insanity) (overflow=4.2%) 191.2 : Insanity Gained from Shadow Crash (insanity) (overflow=35.4%) 61.2 : Insanity Gained from Shadow Word: Death (insanity) (overflow=22.6%) 4.1 : Insanity Gained from Shadow Word: Pain Casts (insanity) (overflow=25.3%) 6.0 : Insanity Gained from Vampiric Touch Casts (insanity) (overflow=12.7%) 1037.8 : Insanity Gained from Void Bolt (insanity) (overflow=33.5%) 220440.0 : Health from Vampiric Touch Ticks (health) (overflow=99.2%) 269.9 : Insanity Gained from Call to the Void (insanity) (overflow=22.4%) 0.0 : mp5_regen (mana) (overflow=100.0%) Waiting: 0.00%

Targets

Actions: Constant Buffs: bleeding/mortal_wounds Dynamic Buffs: Health Decade (0 - 10) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 8.62% benefit= 9% Health Decade (10 - 20) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 8.45% benefit= 8% Health Decade (20 - 30) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 9.06% benefit= 9% Health Decade (30 - 40) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 9.71% benefit=10% Health Decade (40 - 50) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=10.83% benefit=11% Health Decade (50 - 60) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=10.85% benefit=11% Health Decade (60 - 70) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=10.35% benefit=10% Health Decade (70 - 80) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=11.05% benefit=11% Health Decade (80 - 90) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime= 9.04% benefit= 9% Health Decade (90 - 100) : start= 1.0 refresh= 0.0 interval= 0.0 trigger= 0.0 uptime=12.04% benefit=12% Waiting: 0.00% Baseline Performance: RNG Engine = sse2-sfmt Iterations = 997 (265, 246, 244, 242) TotalEvents = 5480952 MaxEventQueue = 49 TargetHealth = 338882832 SimSeconds = 299232 CpuSeconds = 9.281 WallSeconds = 2.429 InitSeconds = 0.434610 MergeSeconds = 0.001159 AnalyzeSeconds= 0.001159 SpeedUp = 32241 EndTime = 2018-05-03 10:52:55+0100 (1525341175)

Waiting: All players active 100% of the time.

Best regards

lgkern commented 6 years ago

Hello and thanks for your report. I created a controlled sim to test exclusively the values from Legacy of the Void with the following results:

Outside VF: 6.572 Anshlun mind_blast hits Fluffy_Pillow for 422687 shadow damage (hit) Inside VF: 11.471 Anshlun mind_blast hits Fluffy_Pillow for 528358 shadow damage (hit)

The difference between hits is 25% (or rather 24.999), which is the expected value. If you want to see the full test you can run the following profile yourself to check: debug=1 single_actor_batch="1" report_details="0" desired_targets="1" iterations="10000" fight_style="Patchwerk" max_time="300" legion.pantheon_trinket_users="am/am/am/am/am/am/am/am/am/am" priest="Anshlun" level="110" race="voidelf" region="us" server="whisperwind" role="spell" professions="tailoring=800/enchanting=800" talents="1111231" spec="shadow" artifact="47:0:0:0:0:1573:4:1574:1:1575:1:1347:1:764:1:765:1:766:1:767:4:768:1:769:1:770:1:771:4:772:4:773:4:774:4:775:4:776:4:1381:1:779:1:778:4:777:4:1650:1" crucible="1739:1771:776/1739:1780:1573/1739:1780:1573" head=",id=151944,bonus_id=3612/1517/3337" neck=",id=137536,enchant_id=5437,bonus_id=3536/1612/3337" shoulder=",id=151950,gem_id=151583,bonus_id=3612/1808/1502/3528" back=",id=152154,enchant_id=5436,bonus_id=3612/1502/3528" chest=",id=152158,bonus_id=3612/1502/3528" tabard=",id=152399" wrist=",id=134436,bonus_id=3536/1582/3337" hands=",id=152155,bonus_id=3612/1502/3528" waist=",id=132864,bonus_id=1811/3630" legs=",id=152157,gem_id=151583,bonus_id=3612/1808/1502/3528" feet=",id=151945,bonus_id=3612/1502/3528" finger1=",id=132452,enchant_id=5428,gem_id=151583,bonus_id=3459/3630" finger2=",id=152284,enchant_id=5428,gem_id=151583,bonus_id=3612/1808/40/1502/3528" main_hand=",id=128827,gem_id=152054/142180/152056,bonus_id=740,relic_id=3611:1522:3337/3536:1572:3337/3612:1502:3528" off_hand=",id=133958" actions="void_eruption/mind_blast/shadow_word_pain/wait"

I built it from my priest's own simc addon extract, removing trinkets and concordance buffs to remove eventual RNG procs. While doing these tests, however, I found a bug that the Priest module is crashing if you never cast Shadow Word: Pain, so thank you for that 😄

Puregold68 commented 6 years ago

Hi and thanks for your reply.

I tested ur profile, and i understand that you done it without trinkets, and concordance, but u also not using vt, mf, void torrent/bolt, etc.

Bit I still not understand how a single target simulation using shadowcrash talents can result in a higher dps than with Legacy of the Void.

Best regards.

lgkern commented 6 years ago

Well, the reason is that Legacy of the Void is tuned to be slightly ahead of Shadow Crash on single target (about 5%) while having appropriate legendaries and high amounts of haste. Farther you get from that situation, better Shadow Crash becomes because of Legacy of the Void is dependant on long Voidforms (around 50 stacks).

Puregold68 commented 6 years ago

Ok thanks a lot for ur reply!

On Fri, May 4, 2018 at 6:17 PM, Lucas Kern notifications@github.com wrote:

Well, the reason is that Legacy of the Void is tuned to be slightly ahead of Shadow Crash on single target (about 5%) while having appropriate legendaries and high amounts of haste. Farther you get from that situation, better Shadow Crash becomes because of Legacy of the Void is dependant on long Voidforms (around 50 stacks).

— You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub https://github.com/simulationcraft/simc/issues/4314#issuecomment-386668323, or mute the thread https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AlIxXVLvZy9b70K9ox6DxIYx2Swuxokyks5tvI0_gaJpZM4Tw0pB .

simulationcraft / simc