search

simulot / immich-go

An alternative to the immich-CLI command that doesn't depend on nodejs installation. It tries its best for importing google photos takeout archives.
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
1.5k stars 47 forks source link

XMP filenames don't always match what is expected #125

Closed dlang123 closed 8 months ago

dlang123 commented 8 months ago

I have imported thousands of photos over the years onto my discs using various programs, using lightroom a lot.

Usually what happens Is I get three files image1.jpg image1.raw (arw lately because of sony) image1.xmp

From what I can tell and what I see from the output of the immich-go cli import 

Scan of the sources:
 21729 files in the input
--------------------------------------------------------
 16371 photos
   391 videos
   305 metadata files
     0 files with metadata
     0 discarded files
   919 files having a type not supported
     0 discarded files because in folder failed videos
 17986 input total (difference 3743)
--------------------------------------------------------
  9080 uploaded files on the server
   142 upgraded files on the server
  7538 files already on the server
     0 discarded files because of options
     2 discarded files because duplicated in the input
     0 discarded files because server has a better image
     0 errors when uploading
 16762 handled total (difference 0)

It finds metadata files, but it doesn't seem to associate those together, unless I am just totally misreading this output. Looking at Immich itself, it seems to think that the sidecar xmp files will be named like : image1.jpg.xmp image1.arw.xmp

Which doesn't seem to be the case for any of the photos from various DSLR's I have imported over the years. Thoughts?

simulot commented 8 months ago

It may have something incoherent with 

   305 metadata files
     0 files with metadata

Also, you have the .jpg, the .raw and the .xmp. I don't know how the system behaves in such case. Will the the xmp associated with the jpg, or the raw or both.

dlang123 commented 8 months ago

It may have something incoherent with

   305 metadata files
     0 files with metadata

Also, you have the .jpg, the .raw and the .xmp. I don't know how the system behaves in such case. Will the the xmp associated with the jpg, or the raw or both.

It should associate with both.

simulot commented 8 months ago

It's a question on immich server behavior

simulot commented 8 months ago

I did some tests. immich-server doesn't associate one XMP to both jpg and raw.

I have implemented this behavior in immich-go. See the release note for details.