search

sinara-hw / DiPho

Digital photodiode with wired and wireless interfaces
5 stars 0 forks source link

[RFC] Other front end boards #2

Open dtcallcock opened 3 years ago

dtcallcock commented 3 years ago

Right now it looks like DiPho will be a two board device, with one board having the photodiode + amp, and one board having the DAC, uC, power, and communications. It has already been mentioned that different versions of the photodiode board could be produced in the future (eg. with log amp). One could imagine a much broader range of applications though (eg. analog front end for voltage monitoring/logging, environmental monitors). I mention it now as, if this is thought to be a good idea, it may influence exactly how things are divided between the two boards and what kind of header should go between them.

dtcallcock commented 3 years ago

Rf power meter + frequency counter is another idea.

gkasprow commented 3 years ago

true, it could be a laser driver, humidity sensor, single channel Sampler, optical power meter, etc. I would expose all pins we have

dhslichter commented 3 years ago

is this too much mission creep? there are a million little commodity IoT widgets out there. I don't think it hurts to expose all available pins, but maybe better to focus on making this a good photodiode monitor first?

dtcallcock commented 3 years ago

better to focus on making this a good photodiode monitor first?

I'd argue that the photodiode aspect of this project is trivial. The 'IoT widget' aspect seems to be the tricky part and thus I think we should consider leveraging effort put in there.

is this too much mission creep?

I think this issue is more about keeping this in mind and not doing anything to preclude it unless there is good reason, rather than creeping the mission.

dhslichter commented 3 years ago

I'd argue that the photodiode aspect of this project is trivial.

Agreed. But making a good photodiode monitor is less about the photodiode circuit and more about the digital side of things, in this instance.

I think this issue is more about keeping this in mind and not doing anything to preclude it unless there is good reason, rather than creeping the mission.

Fair. Just wanted to raise the point. It's already starting to look like the all-singing, all-dancing IoT widget with 4 different communication protocols and 3 connectors and power harvesting and....