sircharlo / meeting-media-manager

A cross platform app to download and present media for congregation meetings of Jehovah’s Witnesses in any language. Features include automatic media downloading, easy drag-and-drop adding of additional media, and media presentation tools for meetings.
https://sircharlo.github.io/meeting-media-manager/
GNU Affero General Public License v3.0
150 stars 27 forks source link

Roadmap and To-Do #2781

Open sircharlo opened 4 months ago

sircharlo commented 4 months ago

Here's a simple tracker of things I'd like to do eventually. I accept code contributions and suggestions!


To-Do / Wishlist

Done / Implemented

ux-git commented 4 months ago

@sircharlo The docs site shuts down completely? Or will be re-written for the new app version?

sircharlo commented 4 months ago

@sircharlo The docs site shuts down completely? Or will be re-written for the new app version?

The current docs will be rendered mostly obsolete with the new version. I also find them quite "heavy".

The new version of M³ is for the most part self-explanatory; perhaps a very simplified docs could replace the existing one; I would prefer to have most essential documentation in the app itself though, with hint text for each setting for example.

ux-git commented 4 months ago

Totally agree! Though, some deeper explanation like a full list of supported formats, settings guide, etc would be great to have on a documentation site, to be able to quickly link to it when needed.

Take a look at Docusaurus, it's pretty user-friendly, with nice essential design, and contribution-open. My experience with it is awesome so far. Plus, in the current GitHub pages documentation, when I open it on mobile, all the languages are mixed up with no way to fix it or to find anything. I didn't face this issue with the Docusaurus.

sircharlo commented 4 months ago

Totally agree! Though, some deeper explanation like a full list of supported formats, settings guide, etc would be great to have on a documentation site, to be able to quickly link to it when needed.

Take a look at Docusaurus, it's pretty user-friendly, with nice essential design, and contribution-open. My experience with it is awesome so far. Plus, in the current GitHub pages documentation, when I open it on mobile, all the languages are mixed up with no way to fix it or to find anything. I didn't face this issue with the Docusaurus.

Very nice!

sircharlo commented 4 months ago

@ux-git In about 5 minutes I will release v24.7.1, which implements almost all of the UI/UX improvements you suggested!

Would you mind taking a look when you can to see if some things need to be further tweaked, or if I missed some screens?

Also, here are some dialogs that I didn't see in your mockups:

Do you think you could take a look and offer some feedback to make the UI consistent for these popups as well?

Thanks so much for your help!

Note: I haven't yet added the caption/explainers to all the settings, but they'll be there for the next release. I just didn't want to wait for that to be done before getting your feedback.

mrtavor commented 4 months ago

Hi @sircharlo, we added a new page in the project in Figma called “Design review”, where we wrote some of the details along with images to make it clearer. Feel free to leave your additional comments there.

Quick overview. Most important things are: • Consistent icons (fill vs stroke & sizes & roundness index) • Apply min-width and max-width for some elements • Meeting media items: title, icon, reorder structure and logic. • Menus and sidebar icon gaps

There are also lower priority points that can be improved and polished. We will mention those in the corresponding priority sections later and will ping you.

mrtavor commented 4 months ago

What is the difference between the Media custom start/stop picker popup and Video stop confirmation popup?

sircharlo commented 4 months ago

What is the difference between the Media custom start/stop picker popup and Video stop confirmation popup?

The video stop popup is what shows up when attempting to stop a video while it is playing; to prevent accidentally stopping a song for example.

The custom start-stop modal is what shows up when you click on the black HH:MM badge on a video. It allows you to set a custom start and stop time for the video (useful for when a congregation is playing a streamed public talk, they can set the start and stop times without having to cut the actual video file).

sircharlo commented 3 months ago

@ux-git @mrtavor I just released 24.7.2 in which the vast majority of the improvements you suggested are implemented. I documented a few icons that appear to be missing from the UI kit, and a few for which I could not find a use. When you have time, I’d love to see your thoughts on what could be still be improved or changed, or things I might have overlooked. Thanks again!

alanfermtz commented 3 months ago

Based on what I have been trying is really good. Its feels smoother. And thanks for adding zoom in to jw org mirroring, its perfect!

Also, worth mentioning its that now I see more often images on both apps (stable, refactor) that are related to watchtower footnotes, and also the brochure love people. Its a bug? If its intended, can you make a exclude button for this cases?

sircharlo commented 3 months ago

Based on what I have been trying is really good. Its feels smoother. And thanks for adding zoom in to jw org mirroring, its perfect!

Thanks so much!

Also, worth mentioning its that now I see more often images on both apps (stable, refactor) that are related to watchtower footnotes, and also the brochure love people. Its a bug? If its intended, can you make a exclude button for this cases?

Did you look into these options in the advanced settings?

image

alanfermtz commented 3 months ago

Yes, I have that enabled I still see all this images:

IMG-20240808-WA0029 IMG-20240808-WA0030

sircharlo commented 3 months ago

Yes, I have that enabled I still see all this images:

Those two pictures are from talk 1. “Tell the Next Generation” About God’s Power, specifically the reference: w14 1/15 23 ¶4-5.

In 2014, the Spanish Watchtower publication files were structured differently, which makes it more difficult to know which paragraph a picture is for. For this reason, all pictures are included.

In other languages, such as English, those pictures don't show up because the publication files are structured in a way that makes it clear which paragraph media relates to.

ux-git commented 3 months ago

@ux-git @mrtavor I just released 24.7.2 in which the vast majority of the improvements you suggested are implemented. I documented a few icons that appear to be missing from the UI kit, and a few for which I could not find a use. When you have time, I’d love to see your thoughts on what could be still be improved or changed, or things I might have overlooked. Thanks again!

Great! Sure, we will take a look, most likely starting from Monday.

mtdvlpr commented 2 months ago

Totally agree! Though, some deeper explanation like a full list of supported formats, settings guide, etc would be great to have on a documentation site, to be able to quickly link to it when needed.

Take a look at Docusaurus, it's pretty user-friendly, with nice essential design, and contribution-open. My experience with it is awesome so far. Plus, in the current GitHub pages documentation, when I open it on mobile, all the languages are mixed up with no way to fix it or to find anything. I didn't face this issue with the Docusaurus.

I would personally recommend VitePress, because it's Vue-based, just like M3 itself. It's very easy to setup and extremely fast!

mtdvlpr commented 1 month ago

Hi @sircharlo, we added a new page in the project in Figma called “Design review”, where we wrote some of the details along with images to make it clearer. Feel free to leave your additional comments there.

Any chance I can be added to that Figma file? I would love to see it and perhaps even contribute my thoughts on it.

ux-git commented 1 day ago

Add a re-fetch button (in settings?) to force a refresh of scheduled media

@sircharlo What about adding the re-fetch button right in the Media sync window? For example one button for all ERROR media. This way it's really intuitive and allows to solve the problem right away [by any brother at the computer] instead of investigating into the settings options [and asking the specific brother who knows where to look at]:

Screenshot 2024-12-02 at 04 54 28