search

skohub-io / skohub-vocabs

A lightweight tool to publish SKOS Vocabularies
https://skohub.io/
Apache License 2.0
32 stars 25 forks source link

Add option to not show notation #302

Open sroertgen opened 2 months ago

sroertgen commented 2 months ago

I recently came across this vocab:

image

which makes me think if there should be an option to not show the notation.

cc @lummerland

acka47 commented 2 months ago

I'd say this is an unintended use of the skos:notation field and it should rather be adjusted on vocab side than at SkoHub Vocabs.

lummerland commented 1 month ago

I'd say this is an unintended use of the skos:notation field and it should rather be adjusted on vocab side than at SkoHub Vocabs.

I would say, the UI concept should be rethought. It might be, that we misused the element here, since the UID seems not to be notation as meant in the specification. But afaik skos:notation has no cardinality and can added multiple times. I don't know if this is a usual case, but for this specific case the UI will not work properly.

In general I question the usability of the notation inside the navigation link. It's surely important to make it visible, but maybe there is a better place?

acka47 commented 1 month ago

But afaik skos:notation has no cardinality and can added multiple times.

I don't understand what this has to do with this specific issue. AFAICS, the concepts in the referenced concept scheme only have one notation, don't they?

In general I question the usability of the notation inside the navigation link. It's surely important to make it visible, but maybe there is a better place?

I don't know. For hierarchical classifications where the notations reflect the hierarchy, this behaviour totally makes sense, see e.g. https://skohub.io/hbz/lobid-vocabs/heads/removeSpatialBase/nwbib.de/subjects.html . For now, I think @sroertgen's approach to support an option to not show notations at all makes sense and would work, wouldn't it?