Closed nmathew98 closed 2 weeks ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐ Score: 85 |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Logic Verification The sorting logic for the keys in `keysFinal` should be verified to ensure it correctly sorts the keys in a case-insensitive manner. The assertion compares the sorted keys with the initial keys, which may not be valid if the initial keys are not sorted. SQL Query Review The SQL query has been modified to include an additional condition. Ensure that this change does not affect the expected results and that it is tested properly. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible bug |
Improve the sorting function to handle nil or empty keys safely___ **Ensure that the sorting function handles cases where keys may be nil or empty toavoid potential panics.** [kryptos/commands/cat_set_test.go [88-90]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/250/files#diff-d00d75b9a98908126bd6ec41a6d5a008e4f9a7eb6235cc354f334ee18cfffbf5R88-R90) ```diff slices.SortStableFunc(keysFinal, func(a string, b string) int { + if a == "" || b == "" { + return 0 // Handle empty strings gracefully + } return strings.Compare(strings.ToLower(a), strings.ToLower(b)) }) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion addresses a potential panic by ensuring the sorting function can handle empty strings, which is a relevant concern for robustness in the code. | 7 |
Possible issue |
Ensure the SQL query accounts for scenarios with no project environments___ **Verify that the SQL query correctly handles cases where no project environmentsexist to avoid unexpected results.** [kryptos/kryptos/kryptos.go [135]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/250/files#diff-52d822dfcf5c61ba100975219c933d7bf9d7eb252bc0bbd2c88c408bb68855edR135-R135) ```diff WHERE NOT EXISTS(SELECT * FROM project_environments WHERE project_environments.key = global_environments.key) +OR (SELECT COUNT(*) FROM project_environments) = 0 ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: The suggestion is relevant as it aims to improve the SQL query's handling of edge cases, but the proposed change does not significantly alter the existing logic, resulting in a moderate score. | 5 |
preview
on authnz/skulpture/shared-authnzPreviewing update (shared-authnz) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/authnz/shared-authnz/previews/1d0169f6-f9ec-4554-bd62-91a215b60691 @ Previewing update..... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update........................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack authnz-shared-authnz running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack authnz-shared-authnz Resources: 4 unchanged
preview
on telemetry/skulpture/shared-telemetryPreviewing update (shared-telemetry) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/telemetry/shared-telemetry/previews/6a66739c-56b4-4f8e-833f-661cc3e7f3de @ Previewing update....... Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update............................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack telemetry-shared-telemetry running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack telemetry-shared-telemetry Resources: 4 unchanged
preview
on network/skulpture/shared-infrastructurePreviewing update (shared-infrastructure) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/network/shared-infrastructure/previews/85b328c3-e52c-409e-9556-672e526527c9 @ Previewing update...... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: starting Downloading plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: done Installing plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: starting Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update..................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack network-shared-infrastructure running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack network-shared-infrastructure Resources: 12 unchanged
preview
on rollout/skulpture/shared-rolloutPreviewing update (shared-rollout) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/rollout/shared-rollout/previews/8bf3a4e8-c9e6-4cff-9363-6f3a4eb4c21d @ Previewing update..... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update.... Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update................................................................................ pulumi:pulumi:Stack rollout-shared-rollout running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack rollout-shared-rollout Resources: 4 unchanged
Title
feat: sort env keys
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests, Other
Description
kryptos/commands/cat_set_test.go
.kryptos/kryptos/kryptos.go
to order environment keys case-insensitively.go.mod
from 1.22.4 to 1.23.0.go.sum
by removing unused dependencies.Changes walkthrough ๐
cat_set_test.go
Add sorting logic and tests for environment keys
kryptos/commands/cat_set_test.go
case-insensitively.
maps
,slices
, andstrings
to support sorting.kryptos.go
Order environment keys case-insensitively in SQL query
kryptos/kryptos/kryptos.go - Modified SQL query to order environment keys case-insensitively.
go.mod
Update Go version in go.mod
kryptos/go.mod - Updated Go version from 1.22.4 to 1.23.0.
go.sum
Clean up go.sum by removing unused dependencies
kryptos/go.sum - Removed unused dependencies.