Closed nmathew98 closed 1 week ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐ Score: 85 |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Code Smell The new code introduces a large number of hardcoded strings for translations. Consider externalizing these strings to a separate localization file or using a more scalable approach for managing translations. Code Complexity The new implementation of the Webauthn authentication process has increased complexity. Ensure that the new script handling is well-documented and tested to avoid potential issues. Code Complexity Similar to WebauthnAuthenticate, the new Webauthn registration process has increased complexity. Review the changes to ensure they are maintainable and well-tested. |
preview
on network/skulpture/shared-infrastructurePreviewing update (shared-infrastructure) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/network/shared-infrastructure/previews/dedde3ae-5c38-42aa-b16b-6d948dd3a590 @ Previewing update...... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: starting Downloading plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: done Installing plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: starting Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Installing plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: done @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update..................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack network-shared-infrastructure running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack network-shared-infrastructure Resources: 12 unchanged
preview
on rollout/skulpture/shared-rolloutPreviewing update (shared-rollout) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/rollout/shared-rollout/previews/be39173c-f193-4f6e-bed3-7e9b39dffc78 @ Previewing update..... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update.... @ Previewing update............................................................................ pulumi:pulumi:Stack rollout-shared-rollout running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack rollout-shared-rollout Resources: 4 unchanged
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Security |
Ensure proper handling of inputs in
___
**Ensure that | 9 |
Ensure that sanitization effectively mitigates XSS risks___ **Validate thatkcSanitize properly handles all potential HTML inputs to prevent XSS vulnerabilities.** [authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/pages/LoginRecoveryAuthnCodeConfig.tsx [150]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-a185440648eb7f02a590c52dcf7b989cf361ba58d62007b2be53746a3fe85a8bR150-R150) ```diff ++ __html: kcSanitize(recoveryCodeListHTML ?? ""), - ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: This suggestion highlights a security concern regarding XSS vulnerabilities, which is important, but it does not propose a specific code change. | 6 | |
Possible issue |
Validate that
___
**Validate that | 8 |
Ensure that
___
**Check that the | 7 | |
Ensure all necessary translation keys are defined to prevent runtime errors___ **Ensure that the translations provided cover all necessary keys to avoid runtimeerrors when accessing undefined properties.** [authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/account/i18n.ts [6-22]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-f647648cf4f6bb7c56cc73df5f93be312bbda30dad62adc74666b0915684e071R6-R22) ```diff + withCustomTranslations({ + en: { + lightTheme: "Light", + darkTheme: "Dark", + systemTheme: "System", + switchTo: "Switch to", + toggleTheme: "Toggle theme", + selectLanguage: "Select language...", + searchLanguage: "Search language...", + noLanguages: "No language found", + hidePassword: "Hide password", + showPassword: "Show password", -+ // Modified base + backToApplication: "Back to application", ++ // Ensure all necessary keys are defined ++ // Add any missing keys here + }, + }) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: The suggestion highlights the importance of ensuring all translation keys are defined, which can prevent runtime errors. However, it lacks specificity on which keys might be missing. | 5 | |
Ensure the condition accurately checks for the presence of social providers___ **Confirm that the conditionrealm.password && social?.providers?.length correctly checks for the existence of providers.** [authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/pages/Login.tsx [100]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-ef8eadc525b8939da4cb654c5a1d1ef3a6d38ba38f26b510720933c91cc12b1eR100-R100) ```diff -+ {realm.password && social?.providers?.length && ( ++ {realm.password && social && social.providers?.length > 0 && ( ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: The suggestion improves the condition to check for social providers more accurately, which is relevant but not critical. | 5 | |
Verify that all required translation keys are included for completeness___ **Ensure that the translations provided in thewithCustomTranslations method are complete and do not miss any necessary keys for other languages.** [authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/i18n.ts [5-6]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-105df81b420322681ad363ea841c68c22996948e0aee79f067b161a66b534951R5-R6) ```diff + .withCustomTranslations({ + en: { ++ // Ensure all necessary keys are included for translations ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 3Why: The suggestion addresses completeness in translations but lacks specificity on which keys are missing, making it a minor improvement. | 3 | |
Possible bug |
Add error handling for missing keys in the environment variable map___ **Handle the case wherecommand.Key does not exist in kryptos.ENVS to avoid potential nil dereference.** [kryptos/commands/grep.go [16]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-5c07349cdd4b74f2e0afc03e5de55ed862eb4d8a3b2ab561e7d37077d177a48bR16-R16) ```diff -value, ok := kryptos.ENVS.Get(command.Key) +value, ok := kryptos.ENVS.Get(command.Key); if !ok { return fmt.Errorf("key not found") } ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion addresses a potential nil dereference issue, which is critical for the stability of the application. Proper error handling is essential. | 8 |
Ensure that the value passed to sanitization is always a valid string___ **Check thatmessagesPerField.get("termsAccepted") returns a valid string before passing it to kcSanitize .**
[authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/pages/Register.tsx [182-183]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-c18f6774f6bc3f2f2570dce7a684a25f90422fb4046224a333afbfd5f2c2bde7R182-R183)
```diff
-+ messagesPerField.get("termsAccepted"),
++ messagesPerField.get("termsAccepted") || "",
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: This suggestion improves robustness by ensuring that a valid string is passed to the sanitization function, which is a good practice. | 7 | |
Ensure proper initialization of the environment variable map to avoid runtime errors___ **Ensure that theENVS variable is initialized before use to prevent nil pointer dereference.** [kryptos/kryptos/kryptos.go [16]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-52d822dfcf5c61ba100975219c933d7bf9d7eb252bc0bbd2c88c408bb68855edR16-R16) ```diff -var ENVS = orderedmap.NewOrderedMap[string, string]() +var ENVS *orderedmap.OrderedMap[string, string] = orderedmap.NewOrderedMap[string, string]() ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves the safety of the code by ensuring that the `ENVS` variable is correctly initialized, which can prevent runtime errors. | 7 | |
Best practice |
Improve uniqueness of the authentication button ID to prevent conflicts___ **Ensure that theauthButtonId is unique across the entire application to avoid potential conflicts.** [authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/pages/WebauthnAuthenticate.tsx [29]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-9a0c86f51c036c183f4ff5ecfd6158df01a9123e16783ece152f288a05635e81R29-R29) ```diff -const authButtonId = "authenticateWebAuthnButton"; +const authButtonId = `authenticateWebAuthnButton-${uniqueIdentifier}`; ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: While ensuring the uniqueness of IDs is a good practice, the suggestion lacks context on how to generate the `uniqueIdentifier`, making it less actionable. | 6 |
Performance |
Optimize output writing by using a buffered writer for better performance___ **Consider using a buffered writer forcommand.View to improve performance when writing multiple lines.** [kryptos/commands/cat.go [16]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/253/files#diff-96f1cde39b6d3133c8e2369e4552a6a5f25b069fe840411a54e563cb7a14c85aR16-R16) ```diff -_, err := fmt.Fprintf(command.View, "%s=%s\n", key, value) +writer := bufio.NewWriter(command.View); _, err := writer.WriteString(fmt.Sprintf("%s=%s\n", key, value)); writer.Flush() ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: While using a buffered writer can improve performance, the actual performance gain may be minimal in this context, making it a lower priority change. | 5 |
preview
on telemetry/skulpture/shared-telemetryPreviewing update (shared-telemetry) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/telemetry/shared-telemetry/previews/b861fcb2-d9fb-42a7-8dcb-80d6bb059723 @ Previewing update..... Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update.......................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack telemetry-shared-telemetry running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack telemetry-shared-telemetry Resources: 4 unchanged
preview
on authnz/skulpture/shared-authnzPreviewing update (shared-authnz) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/authnz/shared-authnz/previews/6b1b4ddd-b154-4b73-8863-ff0619150381 @ Previewing update...... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update.......................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack authnz-shared-authnz running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack authnz-shared-authnz Resources: 4 unchanged
CREATE COLLATION nocase (
provider = icu,
locale = 'en-US',
deterministic = false
);
Title
v0.0.6
PR Type
Enhancement, Bug fix, Tests
Description
i18nBuilder
.useScript
anduseInitialize
.orderedmap
for managing environment variables inkryptos
.kryptos
.package.json
.Changes walkthrough ๐
7 files
i18n.ts
Refactor i18n setup using i18nBuilder for login theme
authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/i18n.ts
createUseI18n
withi18nBuilder
.withCustomTranslations
.build()
.WebauthnAuthenticate.tsx
Refactor WebauthnAuthenticate with useScript hook
authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/pages/WebauthnAuthenticate.tsx
useScript
hook for script management.WebauthnRegister.tsx
Refactor WebauthnRegister with useInitialize hook
authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/pages/WebauthnRegister.tsx
useInitialize
hook for initialization.Template.tsx
Simplify Template component with useInitialize hook
authnz-theme/src/keycloak-theme/login/Template.tsx
useInitialize
hook for initialization.main.tsx
Simplify main entry point with direct KcPage rendering
authnz-theme/src/main.tsx
KcPage
.kryptos.go
Use ordered map for environment variables in Kryptos
kryptos/kryptos/kryptos.go
orderedmap
for environment variable management.orderedmap
forENVS
.ORDER BY
.main.go
Add interactive prompts for environment variables
kryptos/main.go
promptui
.1 files
cat_set_test.go
Add sorting test for environment keys in cat_set_test
kryptos/commands/cat_set_test.go
1 files
package.json
Update dependencies and package manager version
authnz-theme/package.json
packageManager
to a newer version.4 files
docker-compose.yml
Update service replicas and healthcheck in docker-compose
authnz/docker-compose.yml
keycloak
service.docker-compose.proxy.yml
Increase nginx replicas and update ulimits in proxy config
authnz/docker-compose.proxy.yml
nginx
service.ulimits
fornginx
.llm-review.yml
Add GitHub Actions workflow for LLM review
.github/workflows/llm-review.yml - Added new GitHub Actions workflow for LLM review.
dependabot.yml
Add Dependabot configuration for automated updates
.github/dependabot.yml - Added Dependabot configuration for dependency updates.
27 files
pnpm-lock.yaml
...
authnz-theme/pnpm-lock.yaml ...
go.sum
...
kryptos/go.sum ...
go.sum
...
infrastructure/go.sum ...
go.sum
...
authnz/go.sum ...
go.sum
...
rollout/go.sum ...
go.sum
...
telemetry/go.sum ...
go.mod
...
infrastructure/go.mod ...
go.mod
...
kryptos/go.mod ...
docker-compose.yml
...
rollout/docker-compose.yml ...
go.mod
...
authnz/go.mod ...
go.mod
...
rollout/go.mod ...
go.mod
...
telemetry/go.mod ...
docker-compose.yml
...
telemetry/docker-compose.yml ...
deploy-services.yml
...
.github/workflows/deploy-services.yml ...
Dockerfile
...
authnz/keycloak/Dockerfile ...
llm-review.yml
...
.github/workflows/llm-review.yml ...
dependabot.yml
...
.github/dependabot.yml ...
docker-compose.proxy.yml
...
rollout/docker-compose.proxy.yml ...
docker-compose.proxy.yml
...
telemetry/docker-compose.proxy.yml ...
docker-compose.logs.yml
...
telemetry/docker-compose.logs.yml ...
Dockerfile
...
authnz/.devcontainer/Dockerfile ...
nginx.conf
...
authnz/nginx/nginx.conf ...
Dockerfile
...
kryptos/.devcontainer/Dockerfile ...
Dockerfile
...
infrastructure/.devcontainer/Dockerfile ...
Dockerfile
...
rollout/.devcontainer/Dockerfile ...
Dockerfile
...
telemetry/.devcontainer/Dockerfile ...
Dockerfile
...
authnz-theme/.devcontainer/Dockerfile ...