Closed nmathew98 closed 1 week ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐ Score: 85 |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Configuration Change The healthcheck command uses `wget` to check the service's availability. Ensure that `wget` is installed and available in the container environment. Dependency Installation The Dockerfile installs `wget` in a specific build stage. Verify that this does not introduce unnecessary dependencies in the final image. Configuration Change Similar to the previous healthcheck, ensure that the `wget` command is appropriate for the service being monitored. Configuration Change The healthcheck configuration has been updated. Validate that the new settings align with the service's expected behavior. Configuration Change Ensure that the healthcheck for the APM server is correctly configured to reflect its operational status. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Enhancement |
Improve the healthcheck command to ensure proper error handling for authentication failures___ **Validate that the healthcheck command for curl correctly handles authenticationerrors to avoid false positives.** [telemetry/docker-compose.yml [105]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/272/files#diff-a6537addc8ca7f4a881be0eb4c728fcf311c8e0d3f731c6b49e2c14a4672f607R105-R105) ```diff healthcheck: - test: [ "CMD", "sh", "-c", "curl -sf --insecure https://$ELASTIC_USERNAME:$ELASTIC_PASSWORD@localhost:$ELASTICSEARCH_PORT/_cat/health | grep -ioE 'green|yellow' || echo 'not green/yellow cluster status'" ] + test: [ "CMD", "sh", "-c", "curl -sf --insecure https://$ELASTIC_USERNAME:$ELASTIC_PASSWORD@localhost:$ELASTICSEARCH_PORT/_cat/health || { echo 'Healthcheck failed'; exit 1; }" ] ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: This suggestion enhances the healthcheck command by adding error handling for authentication failures, which is important for accurate health status reporting, thus providing a significant improvement. | 6 |
Enhance the healthcheck command to provide clearer failure feedback___ **Consider adjusting the healthcheck command to use a more specific error handlingmechanism to improve reliability.** [rollout/docker-compose.yml [83]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/272/files#diff-be092be3b541d71eab5969ed2268083690f8982a3f84e80e1ba3035ead16882fR83-R83) ```diff healthcheck: - test: [ "CMD-SHELL", "wget --no-verbose --tries=1 --spider http://localhost:8080 || exit 1" ] + test: [ "CMD-SHELL", "wget --no-verbose --tries=1 --spider http://localhost:8080 || { echo 'Healthcheck failed'; exit 1; }" ] ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: The proposed change adds clearer error handling to the healthcheck command, which can improve reliability and debugging, making it a moderate enhancement. | 5 | |
Possible issue |
Update the healthcheck command to use the loopback address for consistency___ **Ensure that the healthcheck command for wget uses the correct URL format to avoidpotential connectivity issues.** [authnz/docker-compose.yml [68-69]](https://github.com/skulpturenz/shared-resources/pull/272/files#diff-85f4696189ef3338eada54f07a4ff1ca1f02d1436164c86af2f549df173ba774R68-R69) ```diff healthcheck: - test: [ "CMD-SHELL", "wget --no-verbose --tries=1 --spider http://localhost:8080 || exit 1" ] + test: [ "CMD-SHELL", "wget --no-verbose --tries=1 --spider http://127.0.0.1:8080 || exit 1" ] ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 3Why: The suggestion to change 'localhost' to '127.0.0.1' is a minor improvement, as both refer to the local machine. This change does not significantly impact functionality. | 3 |
preview
on authnz/skulpture/shared-authnzPreviewing update (shared-authnz) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/authnz/shared-authnz/previews/3be8c705-2484-45c0-99ed-30990f690843 @ Previewing update...... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update........................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack authnz-shared-authnz running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack authnz-shared-authnz Resources: 4 unchanged
preview
on network/skulpture/shared-infrastructurePreviewing update (shared-infrastructure) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/network/shared-infrastructure/previews/25b866a8-c291-4e70-b492-8787940a79f8 @ Previewing update..... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: starting Downloading plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: done Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: starting Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin digitalocean-4.34.0: done @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update........................................................................ pulumi:pulumi:Stack network-shared-infrastructure running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack network-shared-infrastructure Resources: 12 unchanged
preview
on telemetry/skulpture/shared-telemetryPreviewing update (shared-telemetry) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/telemetry/shared-telemetry/previews/483db81d-daf6-4943-b380-f1b34b010051 @ Previewing update...... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done @ Previewing update.... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update........................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack telemetry-shared-telemetry running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack telemetry-shared-telemetry Resources: 4 unchanged
preview
on rollout/skulpture/shared-rolloutPreviewing update (shared-rollout) View Live: https://app.pulumi.com/skulpture/rollout/shared-rollout/previews/3e31be5d-2a76-4b4b-9bbf-919e33887599 @ Previewing update..... Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting Downloading plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done Downloading plugin gcp-7.38.0: done Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: starting @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: starting Installing plugin cloudflare-5.42.0: done @ Previewing update.... Installing plugin gcp-7.38.0: done @ Previewing update............................................................................... pulumi:pulumi:Stack rollout-shared-rollout running @ Previewing update.... pulumi:pulumi:Stack rollout-shared-rollout Resources: 4 unchanged
Title
chore: update healthchecks for keycloak and add wget to final image
PR Type
enhancement, configuration changes
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
docker-compose.yml
Add healthcheck to Keycloak service in Docker Compose
authnz/docker-compose.yml
docker-compose.yml
Update healthcheck configuration in rollout Docker Compose
rollout/docker-compose.yml
docker-compose.yml
Enhance healthcheck settings in telemetry Docker Compose
telemetry/docker-compose.yml
Dockerfile
Add wget installation to Keycloak Dockerfile
authnz/keycloak/Dockerfile