Closed skyl closed 2 weeks ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Code Smell The method names in `CorpusApi` have become quite verbose after the refactoring. Consider simplifying the method names for better readability and maintainability. Data Model Change The `FileResponseSchema` model has been modified to replace the `corpus` field with `corpus_id`. Ensure that this change is compatible with other parts of the system that rely on this model. New Feature The `SplitVectorSearchSchema` model is introduced for vector search functionality. Verify that this new feature is correctly integrated and tested. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible bug |
Add error handling for missing corpus objects to prevent unhandled exceptions___ **Add error handling for cases where thecorpus object is not found to prevent unhandled exceptions.** [py/packages/corpora/routers/corpustextfile.py [20-21]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/16/files#diff-76b598a80f83577973d8fd235d1c9bde05a20e944ac96b5e438fc62f28338146R20-R21) ```diff -corpus = await Corpus.objects.aget(id=payload.corpus_id) +try: + corpus = await Corpus.objects.aget(id=payload.corpus_id) +except Corpus.DoesNotExist: + raise HttpError(404, "Corpus not found.") checksum = compute_checksum(payload.content) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: This suggestion addresses a potential bug by adding error handling for cases where the corpus object is not found. It prevents unhandled exceptions and improves the reliability of the code by providing clear error messages. | 9 |
Possible issue |
Add a validation check to ensure the uploaded tarball is not empty before processing___ **Consider adding a check to ensure that thetarball file is not empty before processing it to prevent unnecessary operations and potential errors.** [py/packages/corpora/routers/corpus.py [27-33]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/16/files#diff-3ac4611171c3ba2b1e471a17f85e949a5df6e835391d39367db05286216d1762R27-R33) ```diff +if not tarball.size: + raise HttpError(400, "Uploaded tarball is empty.") tarball_content: bytes = await sync_to_async(tarball.read)() try: corpus_instance = await Corpus.objects.acreate( name=corpus.name, url=corpus.url, owner=request.user, ) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: This suggestion adds a crucial validation step to ensure that the uploaded tarball is not empty, which prevents unnecessary operations and potential errors. This enhances the robustness of the code by handling a common edge case. | 8 |
Add exception handling for API call to enhance robustness___ **Consider handling potential exceptions that might occur during thecall_api method to ensure robustness.** [py/packages/corpora_client/api/files_api.py [96-98]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/16/files#diff-2dbb7f40c110c352fe705d797c380a367b9088cf0ba3478ce7fb58ea5728f050R96-R98) ```diff -response_data = self.api_client.call_api( - *_param, _request_timeout=_request_timeout -) +try: + response_data = self.api_client.call_api( + *_param, _request_timeout=_request_timeout + ) +except Exception as e: + # Handle exception ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Adding exception handling around the `call_api` method is a good practice to ensure robustness, especially in network operations where failures can occur. | 7 | |
Performance |
Validate the limit parameter in vector search to prevent performance issues___ **Ensure that thelimit parameter in the vector search is validated to prevent excessively large values that could impact performance.** [py/packages/corpora/routers/split.py [28]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/16/files#diff-4c5d6ba850b922ef33f5226408145c898efb20761388266e1c007942a3d6eec2R28-R28) ```diff -.order_by("similarity")[: payload.limit] +.order_by("similarity")[: min(payload.limit, 100)] ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: Limiting the number of results returned by the vector search is a practical measure to prevent performance degradation due to excessively large queries. This suggestion improves the performance and scalability of the application. | 7 |
Maintainability |
Remove unnecessary print statements from test cases to keep output clean___ **Remove theprint(response.content) statement as it is unnecessary and could clutter test output.** [py/packages/corpora/routers/test_split.py [61]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/16/files#diff-6585c521dd30b7828fefa859a692f3234395252d229e08a7ea8fec68581d0834R61-R61) ```diff -print(response.content) assert response.status_code == 200 ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 5Why: Removing unnecessary print statements from test cases helps maintain clean and readable test outputs, which is beneficial for maintainability and debugging. | 5 |
PR Type
enhancement, tests
Description
SplitsApi
,FilesApi
) and refactored existing ones (CorpusApi
) to manage different aspects of the Corpora API.Changes walkthrough ๐
14 files
splits_api.py
Introduce SplitsApi for managing split operations
py/packages/corpora_client/api/splits_api.py
SplitsApi
class for managing split-related API calls.corpus_api.py
Refactor CorpusApi and update method names
py/packages/corpora_client/api/corpus_api.py
CorporaApi
toCorpusApi
.files_api.py
Introduce FilesApi for managing file operations
py/packages/corpora_client/api/files_api.py
FilesApi
class for managing file-related API calls.split_vector_search_schema.py
Add SplitVectorSearchSchema model for vector search
py/packages/corpora_client/models/split_vector_search_schema.py
SplitVectorSearchSchema
model for vector search operations.split_response_schema.py
Add SplitResponseSchema model for split responses
py/packages/corpora_client/models/split_response_schema.py
SplitResponseSchema
model for split response handling.file_response_schema.py
Update FileResponseSchema to include corpus_id
py/packages/corpora_client/models/file_response_schema.py
corpus_id
field toFileResponseSchema
.corpus.py
Add corpus router with CRUD operations
py/packages/corpora/routers/corpus.py
split.py
Add split router with retrieval and search operations
py/packages/corpora/routers/split.py
corpustextfile.py
Add file router with CRUD operations
py/packages/corpora/routers/corpustextfile.py
__init__.py
Update package imports for new API structure
py/packages/corpora_client/__init__.py
CorporaApi
import.schema.py
Update schema definitions for split and file operations
py/packages/corpora/schema.py
SplitVectorSearchSchema
andSplitResponseSchema
to schemadefinitions.
FileResponseSchema
to includecorpus_id
.__init__.py
Update model imports for split schemas
py/packages/corpora_client/models/__init__.py - Updated model imports to include split-related schemas.
router.py
Add main router to aggregate API endpoints
py/packages/corpora/router.py
__init__.py
Update API imports for new structure
py/packages/corpora_client/api/__init__.py
CorpusApi
,FilesApi
, andSplitsApi
.10 files
test_corpus.py
Add test cases for Corpus API operations
py/packages/corpora/routers/test_corpus.py
test_split.py
Add test cases for Split API operations
py/packages/corpora/routers/test_split.py
test_corpustextfile.py
Add test cases for CorpusTextFile API operations
py/packages/corpora/routers/test_corpustextfile.py
test_file_response_schema.py
Update FileResponseSchema tests to include corpus_id
py/packages/corpora_client/test/test_file_response_schema.py
corpus_id
inFileResponseSchema
.test_split_vector_search_schema.py
Add unit tests for SplitVectorSearchSchema
py/packages/corpora_client/test/test_split_vector_search_schema.py
SplitVectorSearchSchema
.test_lib.py
Add test library for creating test data
py/packages/corpora/routers/test_lib.py
test_split_response_schema.py
Add unit tests for SplitResponseSchema
py/packages/corpora_client/test/test_split_response_schema.py
SplitResponseSchema
.test_corpus_api.py
Add unit tests for CorpusApi
py/packages/corpora_client/test/test_corpus_api.py
CorpusApi
.test_splits_api.py
Add unit tests for SplitsApi
py/packages/corpora_client/test/test_splits_api.py
SplitsApi
.test_files_api.py
Add unit tests for FilesApi
py/packages/corpora_client/test/test_files_api.py
FilesApi
.1 files
urls.py
Update URL routing to use new corpora router
py/packages/corpora_proj/urls.py - Updated import to use new `corpora_router`.
1 files
FileResponseSchema.md
Update FileResponseSchema documentation
py/packages/corpora_client/docs/FileResponseSchema.md
corpus_id
inFileResponseSchema
.corpus
field from the schema documentation.7 files
CorpusApi.md
...
py/packages/corpora_client/docs/CorpusApi.md ...
SplitsApi.md
...
py/packages/corpora_client/docs/SplitsApi.md ...
FilesApi.md
...
py/packages/corpora_client/docs/FilesApi.md ...
README.md
...
py/packages/corpora_client/README.md ...
TODO.md
...
TODO.md ...
SplitVectorSearchSchema.md
...
py/packages/corpora_client/docs/SplitVectorSearchSchema.md ...
SplitResponseSchema.md
...
py/packages/corpora_client/docs/SplitResponseSchema.md ...