Closed skyl closed 1 week ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 3 ๐ต๐ต๐ตโชโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Code Smell The `get_file_by_path` function does not handle the case where the file is not found, which might lead to unhandled exceptions. Code Smell The `search` command has commented-out code that should be removed or properly implemented. Code Smell The `get_file_by_path` methods have a lot of repeated code. Consider refactoring to reduce duplication. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Best practice |
Implement error handling for file retrieval to manage potential exceptions___ **Add error handling for thec.file_api.get_file(split.file_id) call to manage potential exceptions and ensure robustness.** [py/packages/corpora_cli/commands/split.py [29-30]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/19/files#diff-05454f1a232d5d3506ccbd1c61a8074269ec8cc48e9d7f8f2f8639f1787708a0R29-R30) ```diff -phial = c.file_api.get_file(split.file_id) -c.console.print(f"File: {phial.path}") +try: + phial = c.file_api.get_file(split.file_id) + c.console.print(f"File: {phial.path}") +except Exception as e: + c.console.print(f"Error retrieving file: {e}", style="bold red") ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding error handling for the file retrieval process is crucial for managing exceptions that may occur, such as network issues or invalid file IDs. This suggestion significantly improves the robustness and user feedback of the application. | 8 |
Add error handling for database retrieval to manage potential exceptions___ **Consider adding error handling for theCorpusTextFile.objects.select_related("corpus").aget call to manage potential exceptions like database access issues.** [py/packages/corpora/routers/corpustextfile.py [50-53]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/19/files#diff-76b598a80f83577973d8fd235d1c9bde05a20e944ac96b5e438fc62f28338146R50-R53) ```diff -ctf = await CorpusTextFile.objects.select_related("corpus").aget( - corpus__id=corpus_id, path=path -) -return ctf +try: + ctf = await CorpusTextFile.objects.select_related("corpus").aget( + corpus__id=corpus_id, path=path + ) + return ctf +except Exception as e: + raise HttpError(500, f"Error retrieving file: {e}") ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion to add error handling for the database retrieval operation is important for managing exceptions like database access issues. This enhances the application's reliability by providing meaningful error messages to the user in case of failures. | 8 | |
Possible issue |
Handle the case where the search result is empty to prevent iteration issues___ **Consider handling the case wherec.split_api.vector_search(query) returns an empty list to avoid potential issues when iterating over res .**
[py/packages/corpora_cli/commands/split.py [26-31]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/19/files#diff-05454f1a232d5d3506ccbd1c61a8074269ec8cc48e9d7f8f2f8639f1787708a0R26-R31)
```diff
res = c.split_api.vector_search(query)
+if not res:
+ c.console.print("No splits found.")
for split in res:
phial = c.file_api.get_file(split.file_id)
c.console.print(f"File: {phial.path}")
c.console.print(f"{split.order} {split.content[:100]}", style="dim")
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion to handle an empty result set from `c.split_api.vector_search(query)` is valuable as it prevents potential runtime errors when iterating over an empty list. This improves the robustness of the code by providing user feedback when no results are found. | 7 |
Possible bug |
Validate the corpus ID from the configuration to ensure it is valid before using it in the search query___ **Ensure that thecorpus_id used in c.config["id"] is valid and exists to prevent potential errors during the search operation.** [py/packages/corpora_cli/commands/split.py [20-24]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/19/files#diff-05454f1a232d5d3506ccbd1c61a8074269ec8cc48e9d7f8f2f8639f1787708a0R20-R24) ```diff +if "id" not in c.config or not c.config["id"]: + raise ValueError("Invalid or missing corpus ID in configuration.") query = SplitVectorSearchSchema( corpus_id=c.config["id"], text=text, limit=limit, ) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Validating the `corpus_id` ensures that the search operation does not proceed with an invalid or missing ID, which could lead to errors. This suggestion enhances the reliability of the code by preventing potential misconfigurations. | 6 |
/describe
PR Description updated to latest commit (https://github.com/skyl/corpora/commit/dc9247ce135c17a822e02606310437c470f4275d)
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
Changes walkthrough ๐
4 files
corpustextfile.py
Add endpoint to retrieve files by path in corpus
py/packages/corpora/routers/corpustextfile.py
split.py
Implement CLI commands for split operations
py/packages/corpora_cli/commands/split.py
main.py
Register split commands in CLI
py/packages/corpora_cli/main.py - Registered new split commands in the CLI application.
file_api.py
Add API client methods for file retrieval by path
py/packages/corpora_client/api/file_api.py
3 files
test_corpustextfile.py
Add tests for file retrieval by path
py/packages/corpora/routers/test_corpustextfile.py
test_split.py
Add tests for CLI split commands
py/packages/corpora_cli/commands/test_split.py
test_file_api.py
Add test case for file retrieval by path
py/packages/corpora_client/test/test_file_api.py - Added a placeholder test case for file retrieval by path.
1 files
.corpora.yaml
Update project metadata in configuration
.corpora.yaml - Updated project ID and name.
2 files
README.md
Document new API method for file retrieval by path
py/packages/corpora_client/README.md - Documented the new API method for file retrieval by path.
FileApi.md
Add documentation for get_file_by_path method
py/packages/corpora_client/docs/FileApi.md - Added documentation for the `get_file_by_path` API method.