Closed skyl closed 1 week ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช No relevant tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Code Smell The `get_relevant_splits` method in the `Corpus` model directly imports and uses `load_llm_provider` within the method. Consider moving the import to the top of the file for better readability and maintainability. Code Smell The `get_issue` function in the `plan` router uses an async call to fetch the `Corpus` object but does not await the `get_data_completion` method. Ensure that all async operations are properly awaited. Error Handling The `get_data_completion` method in `OpenAIClient` raises a generic `RuntimeError` for both `OpenAIError` and `json.JSONDecodeError`. Consider using more specific exception handling to provide clearer error messages. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Possible bug |
Implement error handling for cases where the corpus is not found in the database___ **Add error handling for the case whereCorpus.objects.aget(id=corpus_id) does not find a matching corpus to prevent potential runtime errors.** [py/packages/corpora/routers/plan.py [45-46]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/20/files#diff-d17ee5521ab86acd2823afbc993ced9ea8afb2f074db451ff29c56b83f4e33aaR45-R46) ```diff -corpus = await Corpus.objects.aget(id=corpus_id) +try: + corpus = await Corpus.objects.aget(id=corpus_id) +except Corpus.DoesNotExist: + raise ValueError("Corpus not found") splits = corpus.get_relevant_splits(text) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding error handling for when a corpus is not found prevents potential runtime errors and improves the robustness of the code. This is a significant improvement as it addresses a possible bug. | 8 |
Add a check for missing function arguments before parsing them to prevent runtime errors___ **Ensure that thefunction_args variable is checked for None or empty values before attempting to parse it with json.loads to prevent potential runtime errors.**
[py/packages/corpora_ai_openai/llm_client.py [75-76]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/20/files#diff-de8da8414122015059375c328610dcc9a2d9550504ca03bfaa97ec5eed468407R75-R76)
```diff
function_args = response.choices[0].message.function_call.arguments
+if not function_args:
+ raise RuntimeError("Function arguments are missing")
data_dict = json.loads(function_args)
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: The suggestion adds a necessary check for missing function arguments, which prevents runtime errors and enhances the reliability of the code. This is an important improvement as it addresses a potential bug. | 8 | |
Performance |
Optimize string concatenation by using a list comprehension and joining the strings at the end___ **Consider using a more efficient method to concatenate strings, such as using a listand joining it at the end, to improve performance when building split_context .**
[py/packages/corpora/models.py [54-56]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/20/files#diff-c9de5374aa987d761f770eb99739e686761246600fc6cc0155902d79c9aa3ea5R54-R56)
```diff
-split_context = ""
-for split in splits:
- split_context += f"{split.file.path}\n```\n{split.content}\n```"
+split_context = "\n".join(f"{split.file.path}\n```\n{split.content}\n```" for split in splits)
```
Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion improves performance by using a more efficient method for string concatenation, which is beneficial when dealing with potentially large datasets. This change enhances the code's efficiency without altering its functionality. | 7 |
Next: interface to chat/refine issue and then POST to github.
/ask "get_data_completion
is freaking hot - complete a conversation by returning a defined pydantic BaseModel schema - can you explain how this is so cool?"
get_data_completion
is freaking hot - complete a conversation by returning a defined pydantic basemodel schema - can you explain how this is so cool?
The get_data_completion
method introduced in this PR is indeed a notable enhancement. Here's why it's particularly interesting:
Structured Output: Unlike traditional text generation methods that return unstructured text, get_data_completion
returns data that conforms to a specified Pydantic BaseModel schema. This ensures that the output is not only syntactically correct but also semantically structured according to predefined rules. This is crucial for applications where the output needs to be further processed or integrated into other systems.
Validation and Type Safety: By using Pydantic models, the method leverages Pydantic's validation capabilities. This means that the generated data is automatically validated against the schema, ensuring that it meets all the specified constraints (e.g., types, formats). This reduces the risk of runtime errors due to unexpected data formats.
Integration with OpenAI's Function Calling: The method uses OpenAI's function calling feature, which allows the model to generate structured data directly. This is a powerful feature because it combines the flexibility of language models with the precision of structured data generation, making it suitable for tasks like generating API responses, filling out forms, or creating configuration files.
Error Handling: The implementation includes error handling for both OpenAI API errors and JSON parsing errors. This makes the method robust and reliable, providing clear feedback in case of failures.
Versatility: The method can be used in various contexts where structured data is needed from conversational input. For example, it can be used to generate issue reports, fill out database entries, or even automate parts of a workflow that require specific data formats.
Overall, get_data_completion
enhances the capability of the system to produce reliable, structured outputs from conversational inputs, bridging the gap between natural language processing and structured data requirements.
PR Type
enhancement, other
Description
get_relevant_splits
to theCorpus
model to retrieve relevant text splits using embeddings and cosine similarity.plan
router with an endpoint to generate prospective issues based on text input.get_data_completion
method for generating structured data.get_data_completion
method in theOpenAIClient
to use OpenAI's function calling for structured data generation.Changes walkthrough ๐
models.py
Add method to retrieve relevant text splits using embeddings
py/packages/corpora/models.py
get_relevant_splits
method toCorpus
model.CosineDistance
for similarity calculation.load_llm_provider
for embedding generation.router.py
Integrate plan router into main API router
py/packages/corpora/router.py - Added `plan_router` to the API router.
plan.py
Add plan router with issue creation endpoint
py/packages/corpora/routers/plan.py
plan
router for handling issue creation.IssueSchema
for issue data structure.get_issue
endpoint to generate prospective issues.llm_interface.py
Extend LLM interface with data completion method
py/packages/corpora_ai/llm_interface.py
get_data_completion
abstract method to LLM interface.T
for schema validation.llm_client.py
Implement data completion in OpenAI client
py/packages/corpora_ai_openai/llm_client.py
get_data_completion
method inOpenAIClient
.provider_loader.py
Add provider loader for issue tracking
py/packages/corpora_pm/providers/provider_loader.py