Closed skyl closed 3 weeks ago
Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
โฑ๏ธ Estimated effort to review: 4 ๐ต๐ต๐ต๐ตโช |
๐งช PR contains tests |
๐ No security concerns identified |
โก Recommended focus areas for review Code Smell The `calculate_checksum` function is used directly in the `create_file` endpoint. Consider handling potential exceptions or errors that might arise during checksum calculation. Code Smell The `async_raise_not_found` decorator is catching `ObjectDoesNotExist` and raising `Http404`. Ensure that this behavior is consistent with the rest of the application and that it doesn't mask other potential issues. Possible Bug The `id` field for models `Corpus`, `File`, and `Split` is defined as a `UUIDField`. Ensure that all parts of the application correctly handle UUIDs, especially if there were previous assumptions about integer IDs. |
Explore these optional code suggestions:
Category | Suggestion | Score |
Security |
Use a more secure hashing algorithm for checksum calculations___ **Consider using a more secure hashing algorithm like SHA-256 instead of MD5 forcalculating checksums, as MD5 is considered cryptographically broken and unsuitable for further use.** [py/packages/corpora/lib/files.py [6]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/6/files#diff-43435a16f3377c0d2bfcf1c95a2c2c32d4a15009da949dd89c547e6838db3720R6-R6) ```diff -return hashlib.md5(content.encode("utf-8")).hexdigest() +return hashlib.sha256(content.encode("utf-8")).hexdigest() ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 9Why: Replacing MD5 with SHA-256 significantly improves security, as MD5 is outdated and vulnerable to collision attacks. This suggestion addresses a critical security concern. | 9 |
Enhancement |
Add a test case for handling missing required fields in API requests___ **Add a test case to verify the behavior of the API when attempting to create a corpuswith missing required fields, ensuring that the API handles such cases gracefully.** [py/packages/corpora/test_api.py [14-20]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/6/files#diff-32541e7e6828c01b89b5dced0e66a9d02b5c2fc9d29f4fffc8eb462cf0ea07abR14-R20) ```diff -async def test_create_corpus(self): - payload = {"name": "Test Corpus", "url": "https://example.com/repo"} +async def test_create_corpus_missing_fields(self): + payload = {"url": "https://example.com/repo"} # Missing 'name' response = await client.post("/corpus", json=payload) - assert response.status_code == 201 + assert response.status_code == 400 ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 8Why: Adding a test case for missing required fields enhances test coverage and ensures the API handles such scenarios correctly, improving reliability and robustness. | 8 |
Possible issue |
Ensure the checksum calculation handles different data types for content___ **Ensure that thecalculate_checksum function is called with the correct data type, as it currently expects a string. If payload.content is not guaranteed to be a string, consider converting it or handling other data types appropriately.** [py/packages/corpora/api.py [31]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/6/files#diff-a3bfbda31f4958bd5b403792dd85648527f5192b25bae26a5eb57ac7771e1be6R31-R31) ```diff -checksum = calculate_checksum(payload.content) +checksum = calculate_checksum(str(payload.content)) ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 7Why: The suggestion to ensure that `calculate_checksum` handles different data types is valid, as it prevents potential runtime errors if `payload.content` is not a string. This enhances the robustness of the code. | 7 |
Best practice |
Add logging for exceptions in the async decorator to improve debugging___ **Consider logging the exception details in theasync_raise_not_found decorator before raising the Http404 error to aid in debugging and monitoring.** [py/packages/corpora/lib/dj/decorators.py [13-14]](https://github.com/skyl/corpora/pull/6/files#diff-452f5e0334ec58ce28772c03d7e54074d13d7a18469e2788b2c122b2ed4f0ddcR13-R14) ```diff -except ObjectDoesNotExist: +except ObjectDoesNotExist as e: + logger.error(f"Object not found: {e}") raise Http404("Object not found") ``` Suggestion importance[1-10]: 6Why: Logging exceptions before raising errors can aid in debugging and monitoring, providing valuable context for developers. This is a good practice for maintaining code quality. However, it requires a logger setup which is not shown in the suggestion. | 6 |
PR Type
Enhancement, Tests
Description
NinjaAPI
for managingCorpus
andFile
objects.id
instead ofuuid
for primary keys.ObjectDoesNotExist
exceptions in async views.Changes walkthrough ๐
7 files
api.py
Add asynchronous API endpoints for Corpus and File management
py/packages/corpora/api.py
Corpus
andFile
objects.NinjaAPI
for asynchronous API operations.admin.py
Update admin fields to use ID instead of UUID
py/packages/corpora/admin.py
uuid
withid
forCorpus
model fields in admin display andsearch.
decorators.py
Implement async decorator for handling not found exceptions
py/packages/corpora/lib/dj/decorators.py
ObjectDoesNotExist
exceptions and raiseHttp404
in async views.files.py
Add utility for calculating MD5 checksums
py/packages/corpora/lib/files.py - Implemented a utility function to calculate MD5 checksums.
0002_initial.py
Update migration to use ID for primary keys
py/packages/corpora/migrations/0002_initial.py - Updated migration to use `id` instead of `uuid` for primary keys.
models.py
Modify models to use ID as primary key
py/packages/corpora/models.py
uuid
toid
forCorpus
,File
, andSplit
models.
schema.py
Define schemas for API request and response
py/packages/corpora/schema.py
Corpus
andFile
API requests and responses.4 files
conftest.py
Add pytest fixture for async NinjaAPI client
py/packages/corpora/conftest.py
NinjaAPI.
test_decorators.py
Test async decorator for exception handling
py/packages/corpora/lib/dj/test_decorators.py
async_raise_not_found
decorator.ObjectDoesNotExist
exceptions.test_files.py
Test checksum calculation utility
py/packages/corpora/lib/test_files.py
calculate_checksum
function.test_api.py
Add async tests for API endpoints
py/packages/corpora/test_api.py
Corpus
andFile
.2 files
settings.py
Include Ninja in installed apps
py/packages/testproj/settings.py - Added `ninja` to the list of installed apps.
pytest.ini
Configure pytest for async testing and warnings
py/pytest.ini - Configured pytest to handle async tests and filter warnings.
2 files
TODO.md
Update TODO with API authentication task
TODO.md - Added a note about authentication for API endpoints.
README.md
Document utilities in corpora.lib
py/packages/corpora/lib/README.md - Added README for `corpora.lib` utilities.
2 files
requirements.txt
Update requirements with django-ninja
py/packages/corpora/requirements.txt - Added `django-ninja` to the requirements.
requirements-dev.txt
Add pytest-asyncio to development requirements
py/requirements-dev.txt - Added `pytest-asyncio` to development requirements.