Mischung von mods:nonSort und mods:title über verschiedene mods:titleInfo hinweg

[ChrisBethgster]

Die Titelinformationen folgender mets/mods führen zu einer fehlerhaften Anzeige im DFG-Viewer.

<mods:titleInfo>
    <mods:title>EXAMEN || EORVM QVI AVDI=||VNTVR ANTE RITVM || PVBLICAE ORDINATIONIS, QVA || commendatur eis ministerium EVANGE=||LII. Traditum Vuitebergae || Anno 1554.|| PHILIPPVS MELANT.||(DE CONIV=||GIO.||) (DEFINITIONES || MVLTARVM APPEL=||LATIONVM, QVARVM IN EC=||clesia usus est, traditae à Philippo || Melanth. Torgae & Vuite=||bergae. Anno 1552.|| & 1553.||)</mods:title>
</mods:titleInfo>
<mods:titleInfo type="uniform">
    <mods:nonSort>Der</mods:nonSort>
    <mods:title>Ordinanden Examen</mods:title>
</mods:titleInfo>

Hierbei werden Informationen verschiedener Titel in der Anzeige gemischt. ("Der" + "EXAMEN ||...")

Vollständige METS/MODS: mets_nonSort.zip

[beatrycze-volk]

Die Titelinformationen folgender mets/mods führen zu einer fehlerhaften Anzeige im DFG-Viewer.

<mods:titleInfo>
    <mods:title>EXAMEN || EORVM QVI AVDI=||VNTVR ANTE RITVM || PVBLICAE ORDINATIONIS, QVA || commendatur eis ministerium EVANGE=||LII. Traditum Vuitebergae || Anno 1554.|| PHILIPPVS MELANT.||(DE CONIV=||GIO.||) (DEFINITIONES || MVLTARVM APPEL=||LATIONVM, QVARVM IN EC=||clesia usus est, traditae à Philippo || Melanth. Torgae & Vuite=||bergae. Anno 1552.|| & 1553.||)</mods:title>
</mods:titleInfo>
<mods:titleInfo type="uniform">
    <mods:nonSort>Der</mods:nonSort>
    <mods:title>Ordinanden Examen</mods:title>
</mods:titleInfo>

Hierbei werden Informationen verschiedener Titel in der Anzeige gemischt. ("Der" + "EXAMEN ||...")

Vollständige METS/MODS: mets_nonSort.zip

Is this issue still relevant or can it be closed?

If the problem is still there, could you please elaborate something more? How actually should this title be displayed here?

[ChrisBethgster]

The issue is still relevant.

Example:

• DFG-Viewer: https://dfg-viewer.de/show/?tx_dlf[id]=https%3A%2F%2Fopendata2.uni-halle.de%2Foai%2Fdd%3Fverb%3DGetRecord%26metadataPrefix%3Dmets%26identifier%3Doai%3Aopendata2.uni-halle.de%3A1516514412012%2F1077
• METS/MODS on OAI: https://opendata2.uni-halle.de/oai/dd?verb=GetRecord&metadataPrefix=mets&identifier=oai:opendata2.uni-halle.de:1516514412012/1077
• Section from MODS:

  <mods:titleInfo>
  <mods:title>EXAMEN || EORVM QVI AVDI=||VNTVR ANTE RITVM || PVBLICAE ORDINATIONIS, QVA || commendatur eis ministerium EVANGE=||LII. Traditum Vuitebergae || Anno 1554.|| PHILIPPVS MELANT.||(DE CONIV=||GIO.||) (DEFINITIONES || MVLTARVM APPEL=||LATIONVM, QVARVM IN EC=||clesia usus est, traditae à Philippo || Melanth. Torgae &amp; Vuite=||bergae. Anno 1552.|| &amp; 1553.||)</mods:title>
  </mods:titleInfo>
  <mods:titleInfo type="uniform">
  <mods:nonSort>Der</mods:nonSort>
  <mods:title>Ordinanden Examen</mods:title>
  </mods:titleInfo>
  <mods:titleInfo type="alternative">
  <mods:title>Examen eorum, qui audiuntur ante ritum publicae ordinationis</mods:title>
  </mods:titleInfo>
  ...

  The publication have more than one titles. A complete title is build over the subelements mods:title, mods:nonSort, mods:subTitle of a mods:titleInfo. Different titles (alternate, translated, unform,...) use a new/own mods:titleInfo.

The bug in the dfg-viewer is, a mix over different titles. "Der" + "EXAMEN ||..." (mods:nonSort - second mods:titleInfo, with mods:title from the first mods:titleInfo) The dfg-viewer must not shown all titles, but a mix over the subelements different titles to a new showing title in the UI is absolutely wrong.

Specification for the titles: https://dfg-viewer.de/fileadmin/groups/dfgviewer/MODS-Anwendungsprofil_2.3.1.pdf (page 10 - 12)

[beatrycze-volk]

Thank you very much for explanation. I will look into it.