search

sm00th / bitlbee-discord

Bitlbee plugin for Discord (http://discordapp.com)
GNU General Public License v2.0
290 stars 27 forks source link

Display nicknames rather than server names #55

Open stevesbrain opened 7 years ago

stevesbrain commented 7 years ago

Not sure if this is closely related enough to #40 to warrant it being part of the same issue, but, channels seem to display the account name/username (not sure of the terminology) rather than the per-server nickname. Would be handy to have the per-server nick showing up instead :)

sm00th commented 7 years ago

This happens so because we have a single irc "server" those users "join", and they all show up in &bitlbee control channel.

If you join 2 servers with the same person on them but with 2 different per-server nicks, how do you propose we handle this situation in bitlbee? If we choose a per-server nickname at random and use that for both instances of that user, that would be confusing. If we use global nickname while all non-duplicate users have their per-server nicknames that would be confusing as well. The only solution that won't confuse bitlbee-discord users that I see is adding both nicnames to the control channel, which still might be a bit confusing, is probably a nightmare to implement and is generally a wrong approach in my opinion.

stevesbrain commented 7 years ago

No, you are correct of course - I just didn't think the problem through in relation to the bigger bitlbee picture! Thanks for explaining :)

penny64 commented 6 years ago

Suggesting re-open this- on certain servers I use, nicknames are contextual, informative, and changed frequently. On others they're used for comedic effect which is still part of the conversation. I'm no sure what the best solution is- but one that lets me see people's nicks as they intend for me to see them is necessary to me

@sm00th

penny64 commented 6 years ago

My suggestion would be to make this a channel setting. If enabled, messages are sent to that channel with the fake names, without actually creating any users with those name. The one cost of this is you can't query people in channels with that setting enabled but it seems like the cleanest approach

fastfinge commented 6 years ago

Could bitlbee-discord put the nickname as the real name on IRC? That way it would show up on /whois user. Also, scripts that wanted to parse it to make tooltips or change it on a per channel basis or whatever could easily do so client side. And I feel like client side might be the best place for this to be handled.

sm00th commented 6 years ago

Reopening this due to relatively high demand, and this kinda makes more sense now that friendship_mode is there.

rosborne018 commented 6 years ago

you could have the option to display the nickname after the username like name:nick

Alcaro commented 6 years ago

What if you share two guilds? They're the same person, do they get two nicks or do they talk from wrong nick on the other guild?

What if said person then sends a PM? Which of them does it come from?

I'm sure it's solvable somehow, but like many other issues, it's not as simple as it seems.

jlu5 commented 6 years ago

If we use the name:nick format I wouldn't mind having multiple clients created for one person (having them all forward to the same target).