search

smebberson / docker-alpine

Docker containers running Alpine Linux and s6 for process management. Solid, reliable containers.
MIT License
596 stars 187 forks source link

alpine-base + openjdk #62

Closed rbellamy closed 7 years ago

rbellamy commented 7 years ago

I'd like to see an openjdk-based image using alpine-base.

My team works with the Play Framework, which is perfectly capable of running in the standard "docker way" - except that the openjdk/alpine image doesn't have the s6 overlay, and thus I believe will suffer from the resolv.conf issue, and thus could benefit from the go-dnsmasq functionality you have here.

If there's interest, I will fork and submit a PR.

smebberson commented 7 years ago

Hey @rbellamy, that sounds great. I'd like to see something Java related in here. I don't use it much so don't have the expertise but if you're keen to add it, that'd be great.

It is worth noting and considering however that the latest version of Alpine, 3.4, has fixed all of the resolv.conf issues so go-dnsmasq is technically not required anymore.

rbellamy commented 7 years ago

Well... that's interesting. I didn't realize that. That's really my forcing function here, so I think I'll put this on the back burner for now. Thanks for the heads-up!

smebberson commented 7 years ago

@rbellamy, no worries, I'll close this issue for now but you're welcome to reopen or start a new one should you become interested in this again.

rbellamy commented 7 years ago

I'm a bit confused by something I found in https://github.com/nginxinc/docker-nginx/issues/78. Looks to me like the expected fix in v3.4 of alpine hasn't resolved the problem... am I reading that right?