search

smstuebe / xamarin-fingerprint

Xamarin and MvvMCross plugin for authenticate a user via fingerprint sensor
Microsoft Public License
494 stars 118 forks source link

Cannot Install Release version of Android app with Linking enabled #210

Open gordonsaxby opened 3 years ago

gordonsaxby commented 3 years ago

Steps to reproduce

  1. Add xamarin-fingerprint to a Visual Studio 2019 project, add setup code

  2. Set Release config of Visual Studio project to "Linking = SDK Assemblies Only"

  3. Compile and deploy to an Android device.

Expected behavior

It should compile and deploy successfully to the Android device

Actual behavior

Build succeeds but installation fails (message "Installation of the app failed.")

Crashlog

If something causes an exception paste full stack trace + Exception here

Configuration

Development Environment: Visual Studio 2019 on Windows "Use incremental Android packaging system" ticked Android Package Format = "bundle" Dex compiler = "d8"

Version of the Plugin: 2.1.4

Platform: Android version 10

Device: Nokia 3.4 (testing device but happens on another device too)

I am not using "Code Shrinker" (r8 or ProGuard), I am using Linker setting of "Sdk Assemblies Only" not "Sdk and User Assemblies", so the suggestion here does not apply https://github.com/smstuebe/xamarin-fingerprint#android-code-shrinker-proguard--r8.

I have to set Linker = None in order for the Installation to work. Of course, that means the app will be bigger than it should be.

smsissuechecker commented 3 years ago

Hi @gordonsaxby,

I'm the friendly issue checker. Thanks for using the issue template :star2: I appreciate it very much. I'm sure, the maintainers of this repository will answer, soon.

gordonsaxby commented 3 years ago

Can anyone help with this (rather key) issue?

Rishantkr commented 3 years ago

same problem with me, proguard now obsolete, trying to use r8 and d8 with ' sdk assemblies only' option but can't run on emulator or real device. crashes on immediate start of app.

gordonsaxby commented 2 years ago

Some sort of official comment at least, if not a solution, would be appreciated to acknowledge the issue.

smstuebe commented 2 years ago

@gordonsaxby can you provide logs? If the installation fails, there should be a reason (VS output, android system logs, adb logs)

gordonsaxby commented 2 years ago

@gordonsaxby can you provide logs? If the installation fails, there should be a reason (VS output, android system logs, adb logs)

It appears that the installation failure was because the installed version was compiled in debug mode. I removed the app from the device and then the installation worked.

However, the problem still exists - if I enable Linking = "Sdk Assemblies Only" the app starts (splash screen shows) and then crashes. The app uses "App Center" to record crashes but nothing is logged, so it can't be getting to "OnStart" which is where the AppCenter initialisation takes place.

I have a proguard.cfg file as recommended but it does not appear to help.

I have tried using "LogCat" in Visual Studio but I do not understand it enough to extract anything useful!

My settings are:

image