search

snake-4 / Zygisk-Assistant

A Zygisk module to hide root for KernelSU, Magisk and APatch, designed to work on Android 5.0 and above.
MIT License
1.12k stars 78 forks source link

Magisk Systemless Hosts is detected #4

Closed snake-4 closed 7 months ago

snake-4 commented 7 months ago

Very likely to be the same issue as #2.

Don't use the built-in Systemless Hosts in Magisk. Use a module that does overlay mount instead.

Perhaps https://github.com/symbuzzer/systemless-hosts-KernelSU-module/ would work on Magisk?

AK2H commented 7 months ago

Does the proposed alternative work?

snake-4 commented 7 months ago

Does the proposed alternative work?

Yes.

I'm not sure if Shamiko does something special to hide bind mounts but I don't think so.

AK2H commented 7 months ago

So it's not a flaw in design of your module, but rather an undiscovered trace from Magisk Systemless Hosts which no one found out before, thus it was never adressed by Shamiko.

If so, I guess we can keep using the default module since it's not known to be causing detection problems.

The only way it was discovered is because of the abnormalities Magisk was producing.

snake-4 commented 7 months ago

So it's not a flaw in design of your module, but rather an undiscovered trace from Magisk Systemless Hosts which no one found out before, thus it was never adressed by Shamiko.

If so, I guess we can keep using the default module since it's not known to be causing detection problems.

The only way it was discovered is because of the abnormalities Magisk was producing.

I've just checked with Shamiko and the abnormality is still there. So yeah you could say that.

I can try to implement a method to hide this unexpected change caused by Magisk.

The reason why I closed this issue is because there's a better detailed issue which I referenced in the first comment here.

AK2H commented 7 months ago

Absolutely! I saw the earlier open issue. The reason I asked the question is because you made a recommendation in a closed issue, so I just wanted to clarify some things.