search

snarfed / granary

💬 The social web translator
https://granary.io
Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal
449 stars 57 forks source link

Support Atom "deleted-entry" in conversion #39

Open voxpelli opened 9 years ago

voxpelli commented 9 years ago

This is a crazy and pretty much unrealistic request (time for a "dream" label?) – but I still just want to raise it for future reference as it would actually be a useful feature and it is something the IndieWeb in general should support and also I believe are working on supporting (especially in the context of WebMentions).

The "deleted-entry" spec: https://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc6721

I'm mostly thinking about this in the context of translating an IndieWeb feed to a classic Atom feed – and the thought was triggered by Feedbin saying that they're looking into supporting the "deleted-entry" spec: https://twitter.com/feedbin/status/644977704161312768

snarfed commented 9 years ago

interesting, thanks for filing this!

afaik we don't actually have mf2 markup to represent this in an h-feed yet, right? i could fetch each entry permalink and detect 410s, but that's obviously not ideal.

voxpelli commented 9 years ago

There seems to have been some thoughts on Tombstoning: http://indiewebcamp.com/delete#Tombstoning But currently not in a way that would be consumable through an h-feed it seems – still expects at least a meta-tag that conveys a 410 which means all readers will have to poll the individual entries rather than relying on the feed (and possible Pubsubhubbub updates of it) to find out about deleted posts.

voxpelli commented 9 years ago

Link to IRC discussion about possible h-entry tombstone property: http://indiewebcamp.com/irc/2015-09-20/line/1442768109106

tantek commented 8 years ago

dt-deleted and u-deleted seem like viable options worth exploring

snarfed commented 3 years ago

https://indieweb.org/deleted#Tombstoning